Abstract:Within the mental health field, one of the most influential movements of the past decade is one referred to as evidence-based practice. This movement has sought to systematically identify and promote the implementation of scientifically established treatments. Although this movement emerged as part of the natural need to determine how to best respond to mental health conditions, we suggest that like many social, political, and scientific developments, it is not without its potential dangers, no matter how unintended. In this short piece, we wish to explore three potentially initially unforeseen risks that we believe may have emerged with this movement. These are a loss of focus on (a) the context within which human suffering occurs; (b) what generates change; and (c) how change should be measured. Our intention is to stimulate discussion about possible issues that are arising as this movement progresses. We explicitly, however, do not wish to turn back the clock or support a nostalgic longing for an idealized past. Space constraints limit our ability to comment on the achievements of the evidence-based practice movement, although they are important and notable. The first issue we would like to raise concerns a loss of the importance of appraising the context, meaning, and ultimately culture within which psychological suffering occurs. The evidence-based practice movement has its roots in cautious assessment of what should be addressed by treatment. For instance, careful attention is paid to detecting psychosocial deficits and symptoms and then testing which approaches lead to group differences, often in randomized trials. Symptoms of depression, for example, as measured by questionnaire or interview, have been found to decrease after certain manualized interventions. However, psychological suffering and dysfunction can arise in grossly different contexts and hence mean very different things from person to person. As an example, consider five individuals who have reported the identical symptoms of major depression: prolonged sadness, poor sleep, anhedonia, fatigue, feelings of helplessness, poor concentration, and thoughts of death. Now, consider further that these people are (a) a 25-year-old man who was the driver in a car accident that caused the death of a parent; (b) a 35-year-old woman who has obtained a dream job and found it to be hollow; (c) a 45-year-old woman whose aspirations all seem to be met and can find no root for her distress; (d) a 55-year-old man who has secretly married four different women who have just found out about each other; and (e) a 65-year-old woman struggling to adapt to retirement. In this example, the suffering of each individual, albeit fulfilling the same diagnostic criteria, likely has a significantly different meaning, and it is thus difficult to imagine treatment could proceed without an awareness of those different meanings. Certainly, the evidence-based practice movement does not instruct clinicians to ignore this. The concern we raise, however, is the potential that this essential facet of clinical work—namely consideration of the context and meaning of any specific The Potential Loss of the Who and Why of Human Suffering within Evidence-Based Practice

The potential loss of the who and why of human suffering within evidence-based practice.

Effects of different content of EGCG or caffeic acid addition on the structure, cooking, antioxidant characteristics and in vitro starch digestibility of extruded buckwheat noodles

The Texture of Fresh Rice Noodles As Affected by the Physicochemical Properties and Starch Fine Structure of Aged Paddy

Fortification of Chinese Steamed Bread with Glycyrrhizauralensis Polysaccharides and Evaluation of Its Quality and Performance Attributes.

Microstructural, Textural, Sensory Properties and Quality of Wheat–Yam Composite Flour Noodles

The Effects of Adding Extruded Highland Barley Flour on the Thermomechanical Properties of Wheat Flour Dough and the Overall Quality of Fresh Wet Noodles

The effect of chitosan oligosaccharides on the shelf-life and quality of fresh wet noodles

Effect of adding wheat ( Triticum aestivum L.) farina with varied integrity of endosperm cell wall on dough characteristics, dried noodles quality and starch digestibility

Effect of Ginkgo Biloba Powder on the Physicochemical Properties and Quality Characteristics of Wheat Dough and Fresh Wet Noodles

Effects of different polysaccharides and proteins on dough rheological properties, texture, structure and in vitro starch digestibility of wet sweet potato vermicelli

Interpretation of the effects of hydroxypropyl starch and hydroxypropyl distarch phosphate on frozen raw noodles quality during frozen storage: Studies on water state and starch-gluten network properties

Development of noodles with high highland barley flour incorporation level with proteins and pre‐gelatinized flour/starch

Effects of laminarin on the structural properties and in vitro digestion of wheat starch and its application in noodles

Suppression of axial methionine fluxion in Hydrogenobacter thermophilus Gln64Asn cytochrome c552.

Effect of Resistant Starch Sources on the Physical Properties of Dough and on the Eating Quality and Glycemic Index of Salted Noodles

Quality Evaluation, Storage Stability, and Sensory Characteristics of Wheat Noodles Incorporated with Isomaltodextrin

Effect of soy protein hydrolysates incorporation on dough rheology, protein characteristic, noodle quality, and their correlations

Application of Konjac Glucomannan with Chitosan Coating in Yellow Alkaline Noodles

Effect of Flammulina velutipes Soluble Dietary Fiber on Dough Processing Characteristics and Micro-Fermented Dried Noodles Quality Properties

[Observations on fibrinogenesis in spontaneous hemostasis. II. Demonstration of the early appearance of fibrin in the hemostatic coagulum].

Structural characterization and antioxidant activity of processed polysaccharides PCP-F1 from Polygonatum cyrtonema Hua.