Discovering the Impact of Ronald Gibbons on Dental Research and Beyond
R. Ellen,W. J. Loesche,D. Bratthall
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/154405910508401203
2005-12-01
Abstract:almost all isolates possessed cellulase activity. The dominant anaerobic flora in the rumen had been overlooked. Though Ron did not introduce Hungate's roll-tube technique to oral microbiology, as did Peg Holdeman (later Moore) and Ed Moore, he did bring the knowledge that anaerobes not only dominated on the mucous membranes, but also greatly outnumbered the aerobic flora. This information led to studies on the predominant cultivable flora of supraand subgingival plaque, tongue, and saliva that laid the foundation for our current understanding of oral microbial ecology, and subsequent unraveling of the complex microbial etiology of dental caries and periodontal diseases. These studies established that there were distinct microbial communities in the oral cavity, i.e., the flora of the supragingival plaque was different from that of the subgingival plaque, and that neither plaque contributed significantly to the flora of saliva. The salivary flora was primarily representative of the tongue, explaining why Streptococcus salivarius, the dominant streptococcus in the saliva, could hardly be found on the teeth. The dominant organisms in the supragingival plaque were streptococci identified at the time as Streptococcus sanguis and Streptococcus mitis, and oddly shaped rods called 'diphtheroids', which Ron helped to identify. The dominant organisms in the subgingival plaque were mainly Gramnegative rods suspected to be bacteroides and fusobacteria. Ron had been hired in 1960 by Forsyth Director John B. ['Jack'] Macdonald to work with him and with Sigmund Socransky, one of Jack's former students from Toronto. Together, they continued to exploit a mixed-anaerobic infection model in the guinea pig in which reproducible abscesses could be transmitted by a finite number of oral species, including a black-pigmented bacteroides, known then as Bacteroides melaninogenicus. Though B. melaninogenicus was the key member of the group, its presence depended on nutrients provided by the other organisms. These nutrients were shown to be hemin and menadione (vitamin K) for B. melaninogenicus (the pathogenic type is now known as Porphyromonas gingivalis) and became the focus of one of Gibbons' publications in Science. Growing from this series of studies, Gibbons, Socransky, and Walter Loesche, Ron's first PhD student, standardized laboratory cultivation methods for several types of oral anaerobes. These observations on microbial interactions indicated that bacterial synergisms were an important ecological determinant for the flora found on mucous membranes. In the 1950s, There should be a way to search PubMed to find the Impact Factor (IF) for an individual investigator. If there were an IF for ranking researchers, the late Ronald J. Gibbons ['Ron' to all who knew him] would be the standard, arguably the top-ranked IF of his generation in dental research. Ron Gibbons' legacy is huge in cariology and periodontal research, and way beyond in the fields of anaerobic bacteriology, microbial ecology, bacterial adhesion, and local immunity. A search of MEDLINE spanning the late 1950s to the early 1990s, an era of paper and postal communication that was unimaginably slow by today's broadband standards, would find a great number and incredibly wide range of cutting-edge Gibbons publications that infused our field with novel ideas (Table 1). Yet, a true IF for an investigator should also consider his/her IF as a mentor, the legacy of the teacher, role model, and motivator who populates the research community with a generation of trainees who go on to attain a high IF in their own right (Table 2). We three clinician-scientists of relatively modest IF, who drove our research in distinct directions in three different countries, join together in this "Discovery!" to help the readers of the JDR discover the remarkable international impact of our mentor, Ron Gibbons, in and beyond the field of fundamental oral microbiology.