Effects of Standard-Dose Prophylactic, High-Dose Prophylactic, and Therapeutic Anticoagulation in Patients With Hypoxemic COVID-19 Pneumonia: The ANTICOVID Randomized Clinical Trial
Vincent Labbé,Damien Contou,Nicholas Heming,Bruno Megarbane,Keyvan Razazi,Florence Boissier,Hafid Ait-Oufella,Matthieu Turpin,Serge Carreira,Alexandre Robert,Mehran Monchi,Bertrand Souweine,Sebastien Preau,Denis Doyen,Emmanuel Vivier,Noémie Zucman,Martin Dres,Mohamed Fejjal,Elise Noel-Savina,Marwa Bachir,Karim Jaffal,Jean-François Timsit,Santiago Alberto Picos,Eric Mariotte,Nihal Martis,William Juguet,Giovanna Melica,Paul Rondeau,Etienne Audureau,Armand Mekontso Dessap,ANTICOVID Investigators,Gaetan Plantefevre na,Djillali Annane na,Aurélien Dinh na,Lilia Abdeladim na,Rania Bounab na,Pierre Moine na,Virginie Maxime na,Hayette Tessa na,Miguel Carlos na,Emmanuelle Kuperminc na,Sebastian Voicu na,Isabelle Malissin na,Nicolas Deye na,Aymen M'Rad na,Thomas Lacoste-Palasset na,Thomas Lefevre na,Luc Haudebourg na,Jean-Michel Ekhérian na,François Bagate na,Nicolas de Prost na,Guillaume Carteaux na,Inès Bendib na,Samuel Tuffet na,Julien Lopinto na,Pascale Labedade na,Gaêl Michaud na,Brice Benelli na,Anne Fleur Haudebourg na,Ségolène Gendreau na,Enora Berti na,Astrid Bertier na,Romain Arrestier na,Paul Masi na,Etienne Dufranc na,Remi Coudroy na,Arnaud W Thille na,Anne Veinstein na,Delphine Chatellier na,Jean-Pierre Frat na,Maeva Rodriguez na,Faustine Reynaud na,Victor De Roubin na,François Arrive na,Paul Gabarre na,Diane Bollens na,Patrick Ingiliz na,Benedicte Lefebvre na,Zineb Ouazene na,Thibault Chiarabini na,Nadia Valin na,Tomas Urbina na,Vincent Bonny na,Naike Bige na,Karine Lacombe na,Muriel Fartoukh na,Cyrielle Desnos na,Guillaume Voiriot na,Michel Djibré na,Clarisse Blayau na,Aude Gibelin na,Julien Dessajan na,Ludovic Lassel na,Pierre-Marie Bertrand na,Raphael Chambon na,Nicolas Clément na,Oumar Sy na,Sebastien Jochmans na,Claire Dupuis na,Laure Calvet na,François Thouy na,Kevin Grapin na,Guillaume Laurichesse na,Frederic Kinda na,Pierre Couhault na,Loïc Dopeux na,Julien Goutay na,Geoffrey Ledoux na,Romain Tortuyaux na,Alexandre Gaudet na,Anahita Rouze na,Anne-Sophie Moreau na,Patrick Girardi na,Mercedes Jourdain na,Julien Poissy na,Raphael Favory na,Saadala Nseir na,Matthieu Buscot na,Jean Dellamonica na,Clément Saccheri na,Elisa Demonchy na,David Chirio na,Karine Risso na,Nihal Martis na,Marina Taurel na,Gaël Bourdin na,Pierre Donze na,Christian Pommier na,Sylvène Rosselli na,Marine Simonin na,Jean-Damien Ricard na,Ingrid Thiry na,Santiago Freita Ramos na,Charles Verney na,Fabrice Uhel na,Isabelle Priour na,Damien Roux na,Alexandra Beurton na,Côme Bureau na,Robin Déléris na,Julien Mayaux na,Julien Le Marec na,Safaa Nemlaghi na,Sébastien Clerc na,Aleandre Demoule na,Elise Morawiec na,Benjamin Picard na,Jérémie Pichon na,Pierre Chafiotte na,Sophie Menat na,Sandrine Pontier na,Frédérique Legenne na,Lila Bouadma na,Moustafa Abdel-Nabey na,Tiphaine Girard na,Pierre Jaquet na,Juliette Patrier na,Simona Presente na,Julien Leroy na,Frederic Mechai na,Hugues Cordel na,Nolan Hassold-Rugolino na,Malo Emery na
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1001/jamainternmed.2023.0456
2023-06-01
Abstract:Importance: Given the high risk of thrombosis and anticoagulation-related bleeding in patients with hypoxemic COVID-19 pneumonia, identifying the lowest effective dose of anticoagulation therapy for these patients is imperative. Objectives: To determine whether therapeutic anticoagulation (TA) or high-dose prophylactic anticoagulation (HD-PA) decreases mortality and/or disease duration compared with standard-dose prophylactic anticoagulation (SD-PA), and whether TA outperforms HD-PA; and to compare the net clinical outcomes among the 3 strategies. Design, settings, and participants: The ANTICOVID randomized clinical open-label trial included patients with hypoxemic COVID-19 pneumonia requiring supplemental oxygen and having no initial thrombosis on chest computer tomography with pulmonary angiogram at 23 health centers in France from April 14 to December 13, 2021. Of 339 patients randomized, 334 were included in the primary analysis-114 patients in the SD-PA group, 110 in the HD-PA, and 110 in the TA. At randomization, 90% of the patients were in the intensive care unit. Data analyses were performed from April 13, 2022, to January 3, 2023. Interventions: Patients were randomly assigned (1:1:1) to receive either SD-PA, HD-PA, or TA with low-molecular-weight or unfractionated heparin for 14 days. Main outcomes and measures: A hierarchical criterion of all-cause mortality followed by time to clinical improvement at day 28. Main secondary outcome was net clinical outcome at day 28 (composite of thrombosis, major bleeding, and all-cause death). Results: Among the study population of 334 individuals (mean [SD] age, 58.3 [13.0] years; 226 [67.7%] men and 108 [32.3%] women), use of HD-PA and SD-PA had similar probabilities of favorable outcome (47.3% [95% CI, 39.9% to 54.8%] vs 52.7% [95% CI, 45.2% to 60.1%]; P = .48), as did TA compared with SD-PA (50.9% [95% CI, 43.4% to 58.3%] vs 49.1% [95% CI, 41.7% to 56.6%]; P = .82) and TA compared with HD-PA (53.5% [95% CI 45.8% to 60.9%] vs 46.5% [95% CI, 39.1% to 54.2%]; P = .37). Net clinical outcome was met in 29.8% of patients receiving SD-PA (20.2% thrombosis, 2.6% bleeding, 14.0% death), 16.4% receiving HD-PA (5.5% thrombosis, 3.6% bleeding, 11.8% death), and 20.0% receiving TA (5.5% thrombosis, 3.6% bleeding, 12.7% death). Moreover, HD-PA and TA use significantly reduced thrombosis compared with SD-PA (absolute difference, -14.7 [95% CI -6.2 to -23.2] and -14.7 [95% CI -6.2 to -23.2], respectively). Use of HD-PA significantly reduced net clinical outcome compared with SD-PA (absolute difference, -13.5; 95% CI -2.6 to -24.3). Conclusions and relevance: This randomized clinical trial found that compared with SD-PA, neither HD-PA nor TA use improved the primary hierarchical outcome of all-cause mortality or time to clinical improvement in patients with hypoxemic COVID-19 pneumonia; however, HD-PA resulted in significantly better net clinical outcome by decreasing the risk of de novo thrombosis. Trial registration: ClinicalTrials.gov Identifier: NCT04808882.