Moral Distress Healthcare Providers in Spain: Observational Study
DOI: https://doi.org/10.2147/rmhp.s460360
2024-06-07
Risk Management and Healthcare Policy
Abstract:Marta Mellides González, 1 Marta Elena Losa Iglesias, 2 Inmaculada Corral-Liria, 2 Ricardo Becerro-de-Bengoa-Vallejo, 3 Eva Maria Martinez-Jimenez, 3 Sandra Fares-Medina, 2 Sara González-Martín, 2 Marta San-Antolín, 4 Raquel Jiménez-Fernández 2 1 Hospital Universitario 12 de Octubre, Usera, Madrid, 28041, Spain; 2 Faculty of Health Sciences, Universidad Rey Juan Carlos, Alcorcon, 28922, Spain; 3 Facultad de Enfermería, Fisioterapia y Podología, Universidad Complutense de Madrid, Madrid, 28040, Spain; 4 Department of Psychology, Universidad de Valladolid, Valladolid, 47002, Spain Correspondence: Inmaculada Corral-Liria, Faculty of Health Sciences, Universidad Rey Juan Carlos, Alcorcon, 28922, Spain, Email Objective: To evaluate the moral distress (MD)in health professionals of pediatric and adult units to show how the complexity of care in the pediatric field causes the professionals who carry out their activity in these units to present a higher level of moral distress and a worse climate ethical. Design: Observational study with health professionals who currently work in Spanish Hospitals. Methods: A 58-item questionnaire was electronically distributed which included sociodemographic and employment characteristics, the Spanish version of the Measure of Moral Unrest for Healthcare Professionals (MMD-HP-SPA) and the Hospital Ethical Climate Survey (HECS). Results: A total of 169 health professionals completed the questionnaire. The moral distress was significantly higher among nurses than among physicians and nursing assistant care technicians. Focusing on the type of unit, moral distress it was only significantly higher for those physicians treating adult patients compared to those treating pediatric patients. Regarding the total score of the HECS survey, the medical group shows higher scores compared to the nursing group. Conclusion: Statistically significant differences have been found only in the medical group that treats adult patients, presenting a higher level of moral unrests than the pediatrician group. The MMD-HP-SPA questionnaire is a valid and useful instrument to detect MD in our hospital units in order to be able to implement strategies/interventions that improve the ethical climate and other factors that can mitigate and prevent this MD. Keywords: moral unrest, ethical climate, surveys, questionnaires, pediatrics In 1984, the philosopher Jameton 1 first defined the term moral suffering as the painful psychological imbalance that results from recognizing ethically appropriate action and yet not performing it, due to obstacles such as lack of time, supervisory reluctance, an inhibiting medical power structure, institutional policy, or legal considerations. Addressing the concept of moral distress 2 can be understood as a 'very broad' term, a study on this reflects how, depending on the environment and the different groups of health professionals, it can be understood in different ways, using other terms such as dilemma or ethical confrontation instead of moral distress. Sometimes the difference between the two terms can be subtle: in moral dilemmas there are competing ethical principles, but no principle clearly trumps the other in that situation; On the contrary, in the case of moral distress, the correct course of action is clear, but there are barriers or limitations that prevent health professionals from taking this course of action. Moral distress was originally studied in nurses 3,4 but it has been shown how all health professionals can face doubts about the appropriateness of decisions, treatments or procedures performed in their work, 5,6 causing them to question their behavior and how it affects the quality of the health care they provide. 7 Currently, several instruments have been developed and tested to measure the frequency and intensity of moral distress, 8 taking into account the importance of validation in different cultural contexts. Based on this idea, measurements of moral suffering have been carried out in European countries 8 and in different settings such as pediatric hospital units, 9 in which the appropriateness of use and expand the use of these instruments not only to show the degree of moral anguish they suffer but also to increase knowledge about this term. After conducting a review and not having found in the scientific literature studies investigating moral distress in Spanish pediatric nurses, we present the following study. For that, the aim of this research will be to demonstrate that the complexity of care in the pediatric field causes the profession -Abstract Truncated-
health care sciences & services,health policy & services