Abstract:Ethics in the emerging world of data science are often discussed through cautionary tales about the dire consequences of missteps taken by high profile companies or organizations. We take a different approach by foregrounding the ways that ethics are implicated in the day-to-day work of data science, focusing on instances in which data scientists recognize, grapple with, and conscientiously respond to ethical challenges. This paper presents a case study of ethical dilemmas that arose in a "data science for social good" (DSSG) project focused on improving navigation for people with limited mobility. We describe how this particular DSSG team responded to those dilemmas, and how those responses gave rise to still more dilemmas. While the details of the case discussed here are unique, the ethical dilemmas they illuminate can commonly be found across many DSSG projects. These include: the risk of exacerbating disparities; the thorniness of algorithmic accountability; the evolving opportunities for mischief presented by new technologies; the subjective and value- laden interpretations at the heart of any data-intensive project; the potential for data to amplify or mute particular voices; the possibility of privacy violations; and the folly of technological solutionism. Based on our tracing of the team's responses to these dilemmas, we distill lessons for an ethical data science practice that can be more generally applied across DSSG projects. Specifically, this case experience highlights the importance of: 1) Setting the scene early on for ethical thinking 2) Recognizing ethical decision-making as an emergent phenomenon intertwined with the quotidian work of data science for social good 3) Approaching ethical thinking as a thoughtful and intentional balancing of priorities rather than a binary differentiation between right and wrong.

Web archives for data collection: An ethics case study

Methods and Approaches to Using Web Archives in Computational Communication Research

Using the wayback machine to mine websites in the social sciences: A methodological resource

Big Data Science Over the Past Web

Web archives as a data resource for digital scholars

Archival strategies for contemporary collecting in a world of big data: Challenges and opportunities with curating the UK web archive

Understanding Web Archiving Services and Their (Mis)Use on Social Media

The Use of Web Archives in Disinformation Research

Web Scraping for Research: Legal, Ethical, Institutional, and Scientific Considerations

Web Archives Preserve Our Digital Collective Memory

How to Search the Internet Archive Without Indexing It

Stories From the Past Web

Digital humanities and web archives: Possible new paths for combining datasets

Collecting migrants' Facebook posts: Accounting for ethical measures in a text-as-data approach

Creating Structure in Web Archives With Collections: Different Concepts From Web Archivists

Who and what links to the Internet Archive

Algorithmic thinking in the public interest: navigating technical, legal, and ethical hurdles to web scraping in the social sciences

Ethical Considerations for Responsible Data Curation

Evaluating Personal Archiving Strategies for Internet-based Information

Full-Text and URL Search Over Web Archives

Mapping for accessibility: A case study of ethics in data science for social good