Health Equity for US Asian, Native Hawaiian, and Pacific Islander Populations
Naoko Muramatsu,Marshall H. Chin
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2024.11617
2024-05-22
JAMA Network Open
Abstract:The important article by Sumibcay et al 1 highlights the problem of invisibility for small minoritized populations in the United States. 2 Examining 4 surge periods of high COVID-19 mortality in 2020 to 2021, they found that non-Hispanic American Indian or Alaska Native individuals and Native Hawaiian or Pacific Islander individuals had consistently higher COVID-19 mortality than other racial and ethnic groups. 1 However, if Native Hawaiian or Pacific Islander individuals were combined with Asian individuals, the aggregated Asian–Pacific Islander group would have the lowest mortality rates. Native Hawaiian or Pacific Islander individuals are invisible statistically when aggregated with more numerous Asian individuals; and Native Hawaiian or Pacific Islander individuals are invisible as people when a historical health policy ignores the colonialism and structural racism that led to today's social disadvantage and health inequities. Disaggregating data is just an initial step in advancing health equity. Heterogeneous Native Hawaiian or Pacific Islander and Asian populations need to be truly valued and seen for their diversity, rather than being othered to aggregate categories that do not make sense and dehumanize. 3 ,4 In this Commentary, we discuss how the histories of colonization and structural racism impact health inequities for Native Hawaiian or Pacific Islander and Asian individuals; biases in racial and ethnic categorizations and quantitative data that flow from these histories; and the need for complementary quantitative data analysis, qualitative methods, and culturally appropriate narrative and storytelling to hear the voices of minoritized communities and understand their histories of oppression. History represents what happened, typically from the perspective of the dominant group, and provides insights into the societal structures and institutional biases that contribute to today's health inequities. By the 18th century, European colonizers were exploiting the Pacific islands and their peoples for natural resources and labor and introducing diseases that killed much of the populations. 5 ,6 The United States militarized many islands and, after World War II, conducted nuclear bomb tests in the Marshall Islands, destroying the ecosystem and way of life. Today, compared with other racial and ethnic groups in Hawaii, Native Hawaiian individuals have worse economic status, are more likely to experience homelessness, and have health inequities. 5 Sumibcay et al 1 note likely relationships among structural racism, colonialism, and COVID-19 health inequities for Native Hawaiian or Pacific Islander individuals. Compared with White individuals, Native Hawaiian or Pacific Islander individuals have more poverty, more barriers to accessing health care, more comorbidities, larger households, and a higher percentage of the population in essential worker jobs. 5 ,6 Citizenship status and access to benefits such as health insurance vary across Native Hawaiian or Pacific Islander individuals. 5 ,6 Residents of Hawaii are US citizens, whereas Pacific Islander people from Samoa are noncitizen immigrants to the United States. Three Micronesian nations are members of a Compact for Free Association (COFA), receiving financial and security assistance from the United States in return for military bases. Despite being required to pay taxes, migrants from COFA nations have had varying eligibility for Medicaid depending on the political winds. COFA migrants lost eligibility for Medicaid as part of welfare reform in 1996, and Congress reinstated eligibility in December 2020. Thus, colonialism and structural racism have directly led to social and health inequities for Native Hawaiian or Pacific Islander individuals; moreover, legal status and access to health insurance vary across Native Hawaiian or Pacific Islander individuals in the United States based on this history, making monolithic approaches to advancing health equity for Native Hawaiian or Pacific Islander individuals nonsensical. The problem of invisibility extends beyond Native Hawaiian or Pacific Islander individuals to Asian individuals, where grouping heterogeneous populations into a monolithic Asian category erases evidence of inequities and identification of subgroups that need more resources. 2 ,3 Race and ethnicity categories often represent concepts of the dominant group and are sometimes arbitrary and illogical. For example, Asia is a European concept that aggregates culturally and linguistically diverse lands beyond the eastern border of Europe, making monolithic and invisible more than 50% of the world population. 2 The 2020 Census indicates Asian individuals constitute 6.3% (19 million) of the total US population, including the 6 largest subgroup -Abstract Truncated-
medicine, general & internal