Usefulness of participation of endoscopic surgical skill qualification system-qualified surgeons in laparoscopic high anterior resection
Naruhiko Sawada,Shumpei Mukai,Tomonori Akagi,Ken Okamoto,Fumihiko Fujita,Hirokazu Suwa,Yoshihito Ide,Tomohisa Furuhata,Akiyoshi Kanazawa,Tsukasa Shimamura,Shigehiro Kojima,Shinobu Ohnuma,Tatsuya Kinjo,Nobuki Ichikawa,Shigeki Yamaguchi,Akinobu Taketomi,Takeshi Naitoh,EnSSURE Study Group Collaboratives in the Japan Society of Laparoscopic Colorectal Surgery,Akinobu Furutani,Akiyoshi Noda,Atsushi Ishibe,Chikayoshi Tani,Daisuke Yamamoto,Fuminori Teraishi,Fumio Ishida,Fumitaka Asahara,Heita Ozawa,Hideaki Karasawa,Hideki Osawa,Hiroaki Iijima,Hiroaki Nagano,Hiroaki Takeshita,Hirofumi Ota,Hiroki Ochiai,Hiroomi Ogawa,Hiroshi Saeki,Hirotoshi Hasegawa,Hiroyuki Bando,Hisanaga Horie,Hisashi Nagahara,Jun Watanabe,Kaori Hayashibara,Kay Uehara,Kazuhiro Takehara,Ken Kojo,Kenichiro Saito,Koji Ikeda,Koji Munakata,Koki Goto,Koki Otsuka,Koya Hida,Kunihiko Nagakari,Mamoru Uemura,Manabu Shimomura,Manabu Shiozawa,Manabu Takata,Manabu Yamamoto,Masaaki Ito,Masafumi Inomata,Masahiko Watanabe,Masakatsu Numata,Masashi Miguchi,Masatsune Shibutani,Mayumi Ozawa,Mitsuhisa Takatsuki,Naoya Aisu,Nobuaki Suzuki,Ryo Ikeshima,Ryo Inada,Ryuichi Oshima,Satoshi Maruyama,Shigenori Homma,Shiki Fujino,Shinichiro Mori,Sho Takeda,Shota Aoyama,Shuji Saito,Shusaku Takahashi,Takahiro Sasaki,Takahiro Yamanashi,Takeru Matsuda,Takuya Miura,Tatsunari Fukuoka,Tatsunori Ono,Tatsuya Shonaka,Teni Godai,Tohru Funakoshi,Tomohiro Adachi,Tomohiro Yamaguchi,Toshimoto Kimura,Toshisada Aiba,Toshiya Nagasaki,Toshiyoshi Fujiwara,Tsunekazu Mizushima,Yasuhito Iseki,Yasuo Sumi,Yasushi Rino,Yasuyuki Kamada,Yohei Kurose,Yoshiaki Kita,Yoshiharu Sakai,Yoshihiro Kakeji,Yoshihiro Takashima,Yoshinori Munemoto,Yoshito Akagi,Yoshiyuki Ishii,Yuji Inoue,Yuki Kiyozumi,Yukihito Kokuba,Yukitoshi Todate,Yusuke Sakimura,Yusuke Shimodaira,Yusuke Suwa
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/ases.13409
Abstract:Introduction: A technical qualification system was established by the Japanese Society of Endoscopic Surgery in 2004, and its effectiveness in low anterior resection (LAR) has been reported. We herein performed a subgroup analysis of the effectiveness of the participation of technically qualified surgeons in laparoscopy-assisted high anterior resection (HAR), a procedure used for the technical qualification of surgeons. Methods: The EnSSURE study enrolled 3188 patients who underwent laparoscopic rectal resection for rectal cancer between January 2014 and December 2016 at 56 Japanese hospitals. The outcomes of HAR were compared between groups with and without the participation of technically qualified surgeons. The background of the two groups were equalized by propensity score matching. Results: In the group with the participation of qualified surgeons, the operative time was significantly shorter (p = .0427), more lymph nodes were dissected (p = .0207), and the conversion rate to open surgery was lower (p = .0016); however, no significant difference was observed in blood loss (p = .0616), the R0 resection rate (p = 1.00), intraoperative complication rate (p = .160), postoperative complication rate (p = 1.00), or reoperation rate (p = .6999) between the two groups. Furthermore, no significant difference was noted in long-term outcomes (recurrence-free survival (p = .275) or overall survival (p = .941)). Conclusions: In HAR, the technical benefits of the participation of qualified surgeons was limited to a shorter operative time and lower conversion rate. Nevertheless, the qualification is unique in that it predicts the usefulness of reducing complications in more technically challenging procedures when its effectiveness in LAR is considered.