Patients' preferences for patient centred approach to consultation

J. Skelton
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1136/BMJ.322.7301.1544
2001-06-23
British Medical Journal
Abstract:Editor—Little et al's study seems to show patients' overwhelming preference for a patient centred approach to consultation in primary care.1 The issue is not so much whether most patients agree that, for example, they “want the doctor to understand [their] main reason for coming” as whether a desire for the contrary would represent a belief in some other kind of approach to the consultation or just be plain odd. In other words, what kind of person could possibly say, and be thought rational, “I don't want the doctor to understand my main reason for coming”? I invite readers to review the questionnaire, putting the opposite case in this way and asking themselves how many of the questions are of this type: “I don't want the doctor to be friendly and approachable,” “I don't want the doctor to find out how serious my problem is,” and so on. They might also like to consider how easy it would be to construct a mirror questionnaire, couching doctor centred values in a way that no one could reject (“I want to trust my doctor's expertise”). The difficulty is that there is an implicit contrast in the minds of everyone who works in this field between patient centredness and doctor centredness. The same contrast, though, is not necessarily in the minds of patients, who lack the context of the professional debate. Researchers may believe that patients are expressing a preference for one type of consultation rather than the other, whereas they are simply expressing a preference for the commonsensical rather than the perverse. Patient centredness requires a more sophisticated approach than this.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?