Psychiatric Comorbidities in Functional Neurological Disorders and Psychogenic Non-Epileptic Seizures: A Systematic Review and Policy Recommendations for Improving Assessment and Treatment
Carlo Lazzari,Elda Nikolou-Walker,Liang Liu,Marco Rabottini
DOI: https://doi.org/10.2147/ndt.s491376
IF: 2.989
2024-11-28
Neuropsychiatric Disease and Treatment
Abstract:Carlo Lazzari, 1 Elda Nikolou-Walker, 2 Liang Qin Liu, 2 Marco Rabottini 1 1 Department of Psychiatry, International Centre for Healthcare and Medical Education (ICHME), London, UK; 2 Institute of Health, Social Care & Education, Middlesex University, London, UK Correspondence: Carlo Lazzari, ICHME, International Centre for Healthcare and Medical Education, Milton Keynes, MK7 6BZ, United Kingdom, Email Background: Psychogenic Non-Epileptic Seizures (PNES) and Functional Neurological Disorders (FND) are progressively attracting the attention of healthcare professionals both in the medical or surgical specialties and in psychiatric ones. Methods: Due to FND and PNES complex presentation, often comorbid with other neurological, medical, and psychiatric conditions, starting from our experience with patients presenting with both conditions, we conducted a systematic review of articles that address the comorbidity of PNES and FND with other psychiatric conditions. Results: Our review supports the point that PNES and FND are not autonomous conditions but develop on the grounds of other psychiatric comorbidities including autism, borderline personality disorder (BPD), post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), and alexithymia. Persons with PNES and FND have often a history of child abuse, neglect, and trauma, and these conditions can also trigger the two conditions if appearing later in life. We also propose policies to endorse the comorbidity theory and improve assessment and treatment. Conclusion: The scrutinized studies confirm that PNES and FND might be comorbid or represent manifestations of what we hypothesize as an integrated biopsychosocial model where early trauma, abuse, and neglect lead to a progressive neuro sensitivity that can present in the same person, usually young female patients, as a combination of dysthymia, alexithymia, autism, PTSD, BPD, FND, and PNES. Keywords: functional neurological disorder, psychogenic non-epileptic seizures, comorbidity, psychiatry, borderline personality disorder, autism, post traumatic stress disorder, alexithymia The World Health Organisation – International Classification of Diseases (WHO ICD-11) classifies Functional Neurological Disorder (FND) and Psychogenic Non-Epileptic Seizures (PNES) in 6B60 as Dissociative Neurological Symptom Disorder characterized by the manifestation of motor, sensory, or cognitive symptoms that suggest an involuntary disruption in the typical coordination of motor, sensory, or cognitive functions. 1 These symptoms do not align with any known nervous system disease, mental or behavioral disorder, or other medical condition. 1 The symptoms are not present just during another dissociative illness and are not caused by the effects of a drug or medicine on the central nervous system, including withdrawal effects or a Sleep-Wake disorder. 1 Subclassifications include (1) visual disturbance (6B60.0) such as blindness, tunnel vision, diplopia, visual distortion, or hallucinations; (2) auditory disturbance (6B60.1) with loss of hearing or auditory hallucinations; (3) vertigo (6B60.2) or dizziness; (4) other sensory disturbance (6B60.3) such as numbness, tightness, tingling, burning pain, or other symptoms related to touch, smell, taste, balance, proprioception, kinaesthesia, or thermoception; (5) speech disturbance with dysphonia, aphonia or dysarthria; (6) paresis or weakness; (7) gait disturbance with difficulty in walking, including ataxia; (8) movement disorder such as chorea, myoclonus, tremor, dystonia, facial spasm, parkinsonism or dyskinesia; and (9) cognitive symptoms with impaired memory language and other cognitive areas; (10) other symptoms. 1 Psychogenic Non-epileptic Seizures (PNES) are episodes of altered movement, emotion, sensation, or experience similar to those due to epilepsy but which have purely emotional causes. 2 Some characteristics of PNES are the preserved memory for the events antecedent, during, and after the episodes with a duration of more than two minutes, with rapid recovery after the event, with no post-ictal confusion, and the patient asking what has happened. 3 FND is a condition affecting many young people. 3 It is estimated an incidence of 4–12/1000,000 population per year, with the motor FND affecting 4–5/100,000 per year and PNES 1.5–4.9/100,000 per year. 3 The estimated prevalence for FND is 50/100,000 and for PNES 2–33/100,000 persons. 3 Patients with FND make up 9% of neurology admissions, 16% of neurology clinic referrals, and 10–25% of patients referred to epilepsy specialist centers. 4 In patients with PNES the annual cost of antiepileptic -Abstract Truncated-
psychiatry,clinical neurology