Abstract:Accumulating evidence indicates that the physicochemical properties of biomaterials exert profound influences on stem cell fate decisions. However, matrix-based regulation selected through in vitro analyses based on a given cell population do not genuinely reflect the in vivo conditions, in which multiple cell types are involved and interact dynamically. This study constitutes the first investigation of how macrophages (Mφs) in stiffness-tunable transglutaminase cross-linked gelatin (TG-gel) affect the osteogenesis of bone marrow-derived mesenchymal stem cells (BMMSCs). When a single cell type was cultured, low-stiffness TG-gels promoted BMMSC proliferation, whereas high-stiffness TG-gels supported cell osteogenic differentiation. However, Mφs in high-stiffness TG-gels were more likely to polarize toward the pro-inflammatory M1 phenotype. Using either conditioned medium (CM)-based incubation or Transwell-based co-culture, we found that Mφs encapsulated in the low-stiffness matrix exerted a positive effect on the osteogenesis of co-cultured BMMSCs. Conversely, Mφs in high-stiffness TG-gels negatively affected cell osteogenic differentiation. When both cell types were cultured in the same TG-gel type and placed into the Transwell system, the stiffness-related influences of Mφs on BMMSCs were significantly altered; both the low- and high-stiffness matrix induced similar levels of BMMSC osteogenesis. Although the best material parameter for synergistically affecting Mφs and BMMSCs remains unknown, our data suggest that Mφ involvement in the co-culture system alters previously identified material-related influences on BMMSCs, such as matrix stiffness-related effects, which were identified based on a culture system involving a single cell type. Such Mφ-stem cell interactions should be considered when establishing proper matrix parameter-associated cell regulation in the development of biomimetic biomaterials for regenerative applications. Statement of significance: The substrate stiffness of a scaffold plays critical roles in modulating both reparative cells, such as mesenchymal stem cells (MSCs), and immune cells, such as macrophages (Mφs). Although the influences of material stiffness on either Mφs or MSCs, have been extensively described, how the two cell types respond to matrix cues to dynamically affect each other in a three-dimensional (3D) biosystem remains largely unknown. Here, we report our findings that, in a platform wherein Mφs and bone marrow-derived MSCs coexist, matrix stiffness can influence stem cell fate through both direct matrix-associated regulation and indirect Mφ-based modulation. Our data support future studies of the MSC-Mφ-matrix interplay in the 3D context to optimize matrix parameters for the development of the next biomaterial.

Tailoring surface stiffness to modulate senescent macrophage immunomodulation: Implications for osteo-/angio-genesis in aged bone regeneration

A 'sandwich' Cell Culture Platform with NIR-Responsive Dynamic Stiffness to Modulate Macrophage Phenotypes

Modulating macrophage responses to promote tissue regeneration by changing the formulation of bone extracellular matrix from filler particles to gel bioscaffolds.

Inflammatory Environment-Adaptive Patterned Surface for Spatiotemporal Immunomodulation of Macrophages

NIR‐triggered Hydrogel with Dynamic Stiffness Via Ion Chelation to Modulate Macrophage Phenotypes

Modulating the Phenotype of Host Macrophages to Enhance Osteogenesis in MSC-laden Hydrogels: Design of a Glucomannan Coating Material.

Substrate stiffness can affect the crosstalk between adipose derived mesenchymal stem cells and macrophages in bone tissue engineering

Mineralized Collagen Regulates Macrophage Polarization During Bone Regeneration.

Bone regeneration in inflammation with aging and cell-based immunomodulatory therapy

Impact of Surface Biofunctionalization Strategies on Key Effector Cells Response in Polyacrylamide Hydrogels for Bone Regeneration

Matrix stiffness-induced platelet activation determines immunomodulation of macrophages.

Modulation of Stiffness-Dependent Macrophage Inflammatory Responses by Collagen Deposition

Promoting musculoskeletal system soft tissue regeneration by biomaterial-mediated modulation of macrophage polarization

Modulating immune microenvironment during bone repair using biomaterials: Focusing on the role of macrophages

Macrophage-mediated Immunomodulation in Biomaterial-Assisted Bone Repair: Molecular Insights and Therapeutic Prospects

Regulation of macrophage subtype via injectable micro/nano-structured porous microsphere for reprogramming osteoimmune microenvironment

The immunomodulatory effect of IL-4 accelerates bone substitute material-mediated osteogenesis in aged rats via NLRP3 inflammasome inhibition

Macrophage involvement affects matrix stiffness-related influences on cell osteogenesis under three-dimensional culture conditions

Regulation of Macrophage Polarization and Functional Status by Modulating Hydroxyapatite Ceramic Micro/nano-Topography

Integrated-omics profiling unveils the disparities of host defense to ECM scaffolds during wound healing in aged individuals

Dynamic Stiffening Hydrogel with Instructive Stiffening Timing Modulates Stem Cell Fate in Vitro and Enhances Bone Remodeling in Vivo