Abstract:Red blood cell (RBC) transfusion guidelines correctly promote a general restrictive transfusion approach for anemic hospitalized patients. Such recommendations have been derived from evaluation of specific patient populations, and it is important to recognize that engaging a strict guideline approach has the potential to incur harm if the clinician fails to provide a comprehensive review of the patient's physiological status in determining the benefit and risks of transfusion. We reviewed the data in support of a restrictive or a more liberal RBC transfusion practice, and examined the quality of the datasets and manner of their interpretation to provide better context by which a physician can make a sound decision regarding RBC transfusion therapy. Reviewed studies included PubMed-cited (1974 to 2013) prospective randomized clinical trials, prospective subset analyses of randomized studies, nonrandomized controlled trials, observational case series, consecutive and nonconsecutive case series, and review articles. Prospective randomized clinical trials were acknowledged and emphasized as the best-quality evidence. The results of the analysis support that restrictive RBC transfusion practices appear safe in the hospitalized populations studied, although patients with acute coronary syndromes, traumatic brain injury and patients at risk for brain or spinal cord ischemia were not well represented in the reviewed studies. The lack of quality data regarding the purported adverse effects of RBC transfusion at best suggests that restrictive strategies are no worse than liberal strategies under the studied protocol conditions, and RBC transfusion therapy in the majority of instances represents a marker for greater severity of illness. The conclusion is that in the majority of clinical settings a restrictive RBC transfusion strategy is cost-effective, reduces the risk of adverse events specific to transfusion, and introduces no harm. In anemic patients with ongoing hemorrhage, with risk of significant bleeding, or with concurrent ischemic brain, spinal cord, or myocardium, the optimal hemoglobin transfusion trigger remains unknown. Broad-based adherence to guideline approaches of therapy must respect the individual patient condition as interpreted by comprehensive clinical review.

A Contemporary Review of Blood Transfusion in Critically Ill Patients

Quality Assessment of Established and Emerging Blood Components for Transfusion

RBC Transfusion Strategies in the ICU: A Concise Review

Red Blood Cell Transfusion in Critically Ill Adults: An American College of Chest Physicians Clinical Practice Guideline

To transfuse or not transfuse: an intensive appraisal of red blood cell transfusions in the ICU

Transfusion medicine in India: a survey of current practice

International blood collection and storage: Clinical use of blood products

Controversies related to red blood cell transfusion in critically ill patients

Blood Transfusion in Equids—A Practical Approach and Review

Transfusion strategies in non-bleeding critically ill adults: a clinical practice guideline from the European Society of Intensive Care Medicine

Transfusion practice and safety: current status and possibilities for improvement

Red blood cell transfusion in adult palliative care: a systematic review

Developments in Transfusion Medicine: Pulmonary Transfusion Reactions and Novel Blood Cell Labeling Techniques

Red Blood Cell Transfusion Strategies in Cardiovascular Interventions

Contemporary management of major haemorrhage in critical care

Transfusion in the critically ill: does it affect outcome?

Blood transfusion indications in neurosurgical patients: A systematic review

Restrictive and liberal red cell transfusion strategies in adult patients: reconciling clinical data with best practice

Clinical current status and research progress on transfusion strategy of older patients

Transfusion-related adverse events at the tertiary care center in North India: An institutional hemovigilance effort

A clinical audit of red blood cell transfusion practices at a district hospital in South Africa