Locke on Personal Identity, Consciousness, and “Fatal Errors”

Don Garrett
DOI: https://doi.org/10.5840/PHILTOPICS2003311/214
2003-07-01
Abstract:In a chapter entitled “Of Identity and Diversity” (Essay II.xxvii) written for the second edition of An Essay Concerning Human Understanding, John Locke presents his account of personal identity. It is surely the most famous treatment of that topic in the history of Western philosophy. But while it often draws high marks for originality, it has also been criticized as circular and inconsistent. A common charge of circularity, datable at least to Joseph Butler (1736), is that Locke’s attempt to analyze personal identity in terms of memory fails because memory itself presupposes personal identity. One common charge of inconsistency, datable at least to George Berkeley (1732) and Thomas Reid (1785), is that Locke’s theory of personal identity leads, through the transitivity of identity, to contradictory consequences.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?