Free science under threat

V. Rull

DOI: https://doi.org/10.15252/embr.201541377

IF: 9.071

2016-02-01

EMBO Reports

Abstract:Since its earliest origins in the ancient Greek academies, science has been based on the freedom of human intelligence, creativity and desire to try to understand the world and the human condition. However, this freedom was seldom granted: science and scientists alike have been subjected to religious or political pressures or censorship throughout history. The most popular—and somewhat misunderstood—example is Galileo Galilei, who was forced to renounce the heliocentric view of the solar system under pressure from the Catholic Church because it countered a literal interpretation of the bible that the sun revolves around the Earth. In the 1930s and 1940s, the Soviet agriculturalist Trofim Lysenko used his political influence to silence critics of his theory of vernalism—they were variously fired, imprisoned and executed—and genetics was declared a bourgeois pseudoscience. We might dismiss such events and similar other ones as impossible today, certain that the days of religious or political pressure on research are gone. But we should not be so sure: contemporary science seems again to be coming under pressure from political, social and religious actors. While they do not have the murderous intent of historical censors, they nonetheless threaten the freedom of science. It is worthwhile to remember that the freedom of science as we know and enjoy it today is a recent accomplishment. Before the industrial revolution, research was mainly funded by rich individuals and universities—which relied on funds from private contributors—or the church: Isaac Newton was a fellow of Trinity College; Charles Darwin joined the crew of the Beagle as a self‐funded naturalist; Gregor Mendel performed his experiments on inheritance in the confines of a cloister. These privately funded endeavours began to change with the rise of the modern university, where scientists were formally employed, and progress accelerated during and after World War II when the …