Liposomes and the physico‐chemical basis of unconsciousness
A. Bangham
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1096/fj.05-1103ufm
2005-11-01
The FASEB Journal
Abstract:Bill Bryson, who has the temerity to have written A Short History of Nearly Everything (1), claims that little is known about the causes of deep diving narcosis. He acknowledges that it is related to the abundant atmospheric gas, but fails to note that any gas soluble in a nonaqueous phase will partition into the typically phospholipid rich biological cell membrane. As it happens, a paper on the subject was published from my laboratory at Babraham, many years ago (2). Our paper established that nitrogen (and argon) penetrate membrane phospholipids under pressure and the extent of the adsorption was in rough agreement with that for typical volatile anesthetic agents such as ether, chloroform, and halothane, usually administered at atmospheric pressure. Significantly, helium showed no evidence of penetration up to a pressure of 800 pounds per square inch, hence the success of “Heliox”. We received little feedback and the significance of our result was not appreciated by us at the time. Now, some 38 years later, I’ve taken the opportunity to remind readers of this Bryson’s modestly titled compendium— and of The FASEB Journal—of the results and conclusions of some 27 peer-reviewed papers on the subject of anesthetic action. Keith Miller, of the Department of Anesthesia, Massachusetts General Hospital, wrote of liposomes as follows: “To a field whose most powerful model nearly seven decades ago had been a jar of olive oil, the liposome's arrival was a liberating force.” (3) Sheena Johnson in my laboratory and Miller at Oxford confirmed that just as anaesthetized animals could be reawakened under pressure, so could leaky liposomes (4). Sheena Johnson subsequently published substantial experimental data relating to the thermodynamic parameters of anesthetic concentration, temperature, and pressure on the leakiness of liposomes to cations. Martyn Hill summarized her data by the generalization that the cation permeability of liposomes can be analyzed in terms of rate theory, the activation enthalpy DH* being characteristic of the system but being independent of the presence or absence of anesthetics. The fact that the anesthetics tended to increase the permeability and hence the free energy of activation DG*, but not DV* or DH*, means that DS*, the entropy of activation, must change since DG* DH* PDV* – TDS*. This indicates that anesthetics and/or a raised temperature operate by changing the entropy of the membrane and that hydrostatic pressure counteracts the ensuing (membrane) disorder (5) Liposomes were responding, it would appear, as perfect thermodynamic models, a conclusion that immediately bears on the confusion surrounding the mechanism whereby nitrogen mediates the narcosis of deep diving. The conflict is evident: to compromise liposomes a high concentration of nitrogen is required, a concentration achieved only by high pressure. But, pressure reduces solubility into the phospholipid model! Likewise, the whole body of an animal would also be affected by high pressure and is well known to compromise the effect of anesthetics. Little wonder Bill Bryson is bemused. The same conflict arises if and when whole animals are anesthetized at raised temperature. The thermodynamic model would predict lower concentrations of anesthetic to be necessary, contrary to clinical experience, but raised temperature of the whole body system could also be expected to enhance the activity of many enzymes. Liposomes were appealing to us as models in this regard, because they could be made to resemble synaptic neurotransmitter vesicles both in composition and size. Ironically “synaptosomes” were first isolated by Victor Whittaker and Sheridan at Babraham (Cambridge) in a laboratory adjacent to mine (6). We were also aware that neurotransmitters were characteristically weak amines (e.g., adrenaline, dopamine, and 5 HT) and had shown they could be concentrated inside liposomes (7). We therefore proposed a proton pump/ leak hypothesis to account for a compromised CNS or a state of unconsciousness (8). Could the liposome data support the classic Meyer hypothesis which declared that “the narcotising substance enters into a loose physico-chemical combination with the vitally important lipids of the cell, perhaps with lecithin” and discussed at length by Miller (3)? We decided to test it on whole animals (actually, fish). If disordered and leaky synaptosomes compromised normal function of the CNS, warming of the whole body might lower the required anesthetic dose for a given level of unconsciousness, and on the other hand at low body temperature or under high pressure, higher concentrations would be required. Almost the opposite was observed (9)! Nevertheless, Deamer and I found ourselves confidently able to