Abstract:Objective: To determine whether long-term results of one of three different management protocols for severe tibial pilon fractures offer advantages over the other two. Design: In a retrospective study, patients were examined clinically and radiologically after internal fixation of severe tibial plafond fractures (i.e., 92 percent Type C fractures according to the AO-ASIF classification). Setting: Department of Traumatology, Hanover Medical School. Level I trauma center. Patients: Fifty-one of seventy-seven patients treated between 1982 and 1992 were examined clinically and radiologically at an average of sixty-eight months (range 13 to 130 months) after injury. Interventions: The patients were treated in three different ways: primary internal fixation with a plate following the AO-ASIF principles (n = 15), which was reserved for patients with closed fractures without severe soft tissue trauma; one-stage minimally invasive osteosynthesis for reconstruction of the articular surface with long-term transarticular external fixation of the ankle for at least four weeks (n = 28); and a two-stage procedure entailing primary reduction and reconstruction of the articular surface with minimally invasive osteosynthesis and short-term transarticular external fixation of the ankle joint followed by secondary medial stabilization with a plate using a technique requiring only limited skin incisions (a reduced invasive technique) (n = 8). Main outcome measurements: Objective evaluation criteria were infection rate, amount of posttraumatic arthritis, range of ankle movement, and number of arthrodeses. Subjective criteria were pain, swelling, and restriction of work or leisure activities. Results: Because only closed fractures were treated by primary internal fixation with a plate, there was a statistically significant difference (p < 0.005) in the distribution of open fractures between the three treatment groups. Fracture classification in these groups were not significantly different. All but four fractures were classified as Type C lesions according to the AO-ASIF system. The soft tissue was closed in 63 percent (n = 32) and open in 37 percent (n = 19). No significant relationship could be found between the soft tissue damage and degree of arthritis or between the type of surgical treatment and extent of posttraumatic arthritis. However, none of the patients who required secondary arthrodesis (23 percent of all cases) were in the group who had undergone two-step surgery (p < 0.05). The range of ankle movement was much greater in the two-step group than in the others; these patients also had less pain, more frequently continued working in their previous profession, and had fewer limitations in their leisure activities. These differences did not reach statistical significance. The incidence of wound infection did not differ significantly among the three groups. Conclusions: On the basis of our results, we now prefer a two-step procedure for the treatment of severe tibial pilon fractures with extensive soft tissue damage. In the first stage, primary reduction and internal fixation of the articular surface is performed using stab incisions, screws, and K-wires. Temporary external fixation is applied across the ankle joint. After recovery of the soft tissues, the second stage entails internal fixation with a medial plate using a reduced invasive technique.

Severe Pilon Fractures: The Role of Quality of Reduction in Clinical and Functional Outcomes

Evaluation of Functional Outcome in Surgically Managed Tibial Pilon Fractures

Surgical options for the treatment of severe tibial pilon fractures: a study of three techniques

Injury Mechanism, Fracture Characteristics and Clinical Treatment of Pilon Fracture with Intact Fibula-a Retrospective Study of 23 Pilon Fractures.

Treatment of AO/OTA 43-C3 Pilon Fracture: Be Aware of Posterior Column Malreduction

The Summary of Characteristic and Treatment of Pilon Fracture with Intact Fibula

Study on Treatment of Pilon Fracture with Emergent Open Reduction and Limited Internal Fixation Combined with External Fixator

[Operative techniques and results of tibial pilon fractures]

Surgical Treatment Strategy for Tibial Pilon Fracture

A Retrospective Study of the Clinical Outcomes of Pilon Variant Posterior Malleolar Fracture Involving Intra-Articular Impacted Fragments

Influence of reduction quality on functional outcome and quality of life in the surgical treatment of tibial plateau fractures: A retrospective cohort study

Open reduction and internal fixation combined with Ilizarov joint distraction for treatment of comminuted talar body fractures

Reinforced bar-ring Hybrid external fixator combined with limited internal fixation for complex fractures of tibial plateau

Pilon fracture with central articular surface collapse treated by posterior tibial fenestration indirect reduction and compression technique: Two cases report

[Clinical analysis of Pilon fractures treated through a single lateral approach for 28 patients]

Evaluation of Results of Open Reduction and Internal Fixation (ORIF) of Fracture of Distal End of Femur with Intra-Articular Extension

[Over-articular external fixator combined with limited internal fixation for the treatment of high-energy Pilon fractures]

A new surgical strategy for the treatment of tibial pilon fractures with MIPO facilitated by double reverse traction repositor

Early posterior column internal fixation: A staged treatment of type C3 tibial pilon fracture

FIXATION OF POSTERIOR TIBIAL PLATEAU FRACTURE AND ITS OUTCOME: A COMPARATIVE STUDY

Open Reduction Internal Fixation With Transverse Volar Plating for Unstable Proximal Interphalangeal Fracture-Dislocation: The Seatbelt Procedure