Performance Characteristics of NGS-Based Engraftment Monitoring and Microchimerism Detection in Allogeneic Hematopoietic Cell Transplantation: A Practical Approach for Clinical Assay Validation

Amanda Germaine Blouin,Wyatt Nelson,Daniel Geraghty,Medhat Askar,Fei Ye
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jmoldx.2024.07.003
2024-08-22
Abstract:Chimerism analysis by Next-Generation Sequencing (NGS) is an emerging method for engraftment monitoring post-allogeneic hematopoietic cell transplantation. A high-sensitivity methodology is required for the detection of microchimerism (< 1 % chimerism) which may have clinical utility in early relapse detection, allograft monitoring in organ transplantation and other allogeneic cellular therapies (such as microtransplantations). As more clinical laboratories adopt this methodology, a thorough assessment of performance is needed. This study evaluated one such NGS-based assay that utilizes both SNPs and InDels as genetic markers. An assessment of accuracy, linearity, sensitivity and reproducibility was performed. Analytical sensitivity was 0.2 % donor for single donor and 0.5 % donors for double donors. The assay showed a high degree of reproducibility over a full range of chimerism. Comparison to STR-PCR showed high concordance; yet below 5 % chimerism was consistently detected by NGS, but not by STR-PCR. Comparison to qPCR showed high concordance, but with lower correlation in the mid-range (40-60 % chimerism). Overall, the assay showed consistent performance with high sensitivity and accuracy compared to STR-PCR and qPCR across a full range of chimerism in the setting of single and multi-donor transplantations. In addition, criteria for quality metrics were established for sequencing performance and data analysis. We conclude with a discussion of considerations for clinical laboratory validation of NGS-based chimerism assay and analysis software.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?