Bronchoalveolar Lavage Fluid Cellular Analysis and Radiologic Patterns in Patients with Fibrotic Interstitial Lung Disease

Aamanda Grant-Orser,Michael Asmussen,Daniel-Costin Marinescu,Cameron J Hague,Nestor L Muller,Darra T Murphy,Andrew Churg,Joanne L Wright,Amna Al-Arnawoot,Ana-Maria Bilawich,Patrick Bourgouin,Gerald Cox,Celine Durand,Tracy Elliot,Jennifer Ellis,Jolene H Fisher,Derek Fladeland,Gillian C Goobie,Zachary Guenther,Ehsan Haider,Nathan Hambly,James Huynh,Geoffrey Karjala,Nasreen Khalil,Martin Kolb,Jonathon Leipsic,Stacey Lok,Sarah MacIsaac,Micheal McInnis,Helene Manganas,Veronica Marcoux,John Mayo,Julie Morisset,Ciaran Scallan,Tony Sedlic,Shane Shapera,Kelly Sun,Victoria Tan,Alyson W Wong,Boyang Zheng,Christopher J Ryerson,Kerri A Johannson
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.chest.2024.07.166
IF: 9.6
2024-08-21
Chest
Abstract:Background: Bronchoalveolar lavage (BAL) cellular analysis is often recommended during the initial diagnostic evaluation of fibrotic ILD. Despite recommendation for its use, between-center heterogeneity exists and supportive data concerning the clinical utility and correlation of BAL findings with radiologic features or patterns remains sparse. Research question: In patients with fibrotic ILD, are BAL findings associated with radiologic features, patterns, and clinical diagnoses? Methods: Patients with fibrotic ILD who underwent BAL for diagnostic evaluation and enrolled in the prospective Canadian Registry for Pulmonary Fibrosis were re-reviewed in a standardized multidisciplinary discussion (MDD). BAL was categorized according to guideline-recommended thresholds, and also using thresholds of lymphocytosis>20% and neutrophils>4.5%. High-resolution computed tomography (HRCT) scans were scored (blinded to clinical data) for specific features and percentage lung involvement. Radiologists classified HRCTs according to guideline-defined patterns for idiopathic pulmonary fibrosis (IPF) and fibrotic hypersensitivity pneumonitis (fHP), then MDD diagnoses were assigned, considering all available data. Results: Bronchoscopy with cellular analysis was performed in 209/1593 (13%) patients. Lymphocyte% was weakly negatively correlated with total fibrosis% (r=-0.16, p=0.023) but not statistically significantly correlated with ground glass opacity% (r=0.01, p=0.94). A mixed BAL pattern was the most frequent in all radiologic patterns (range 45% to 69%), with a minority classifiable according to BAL guidelines. BAL lymphocytosis appeared with similar frequency across HRCT patterns of fHP (21%) and UIP (18%). Only 5% of patients with MDD-based fHP had a guideline defined isolated lymphocytosis >15%. Interpretation: BAL cellular analyses did not significantly correlate with radiologic features, guideline patterns, or MDD-based diagnoses. Ground glass opacities are often interpreted to represent pulmonary inflammation, but were not associated with BAL lymphocytosis in this cohort.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?