Knee muscle strength and steadiness for individuals with anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction and knee osteoarthritis

Nicholas L Hunt,Matthew V Robinett,Tyler N Brown

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.clinbiomech.2024.106331

Abstract:Background: Strength and neuromuscular decrements following knee musculoskeletal injury may accelerate knee osteoarthritis development. This study assessed isometric knee extensor and flexor strength and steadiness between individuals with knee injury, i.e., ligament reconstruction, and knee osteoarthritis to healthy age-matched controls. Methods: Four cohorts (1: knee injury and 2: age-matched controls, and 3: radiographic knee osteoarthritis and 4: age-matched controls) were recruited. Participants performed maximal voluntary isometric knee extensor and flexor contractions. Then, strength (e.g., peak and rate of torque development) and steadiness (e.g., peak power, mean, and median frequency) were derived from each raw torque-time curve and associated power spectral density. A Kruskal-Wallis H test and Spearman's rho correlation analysis assessed cohort differences and association between knee extensor and flexor strength and steadiness. Findings: The young adult control and knee injury cohorts exhibited greater knee extensor and flexor strength than the older, knee osteoarthritis cohort (p < 0.043). The knee injury cohort, despite being as strong as their healthy counterparts, were significantly less steady with a 92% increase in peak power frequency (p = 0.046). The osteoarthritis cohort exhibited 157% less total power compared to the knee injury and young control cohorts (p < 0.019). Knee extensor and flexor peak torque, rate of torque development, and mean torque exhibit a significant, positive relation with total power (p < 0.018). Interpretation: Individuals with knee injury and disease may exhibit weaker or less steady knee musculature, predisposing them to degenerative joint disease. Clinicians may need to restore knee extensor and flexor steadiness to facilitate better joint neuromuscular control.