Could H5N1 bird flu virus be the cause of the next human pandemic?
Giorgio Palù,Pier Francesco Roggero,Arianna Calistri
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3389/fmicb.2024.1477738
IF: 5.2
2024-10-08
Frontiers in Microbiology
Abstract:Highly pathogenic type A avian influenza (HPAI) viruses have been affecting numerous wild and domestic avian species worldwide over the past decades and continue to circulate, causing significant damage to the poultry industry (CDC, 2024a). Since 2021, numerous regions worldwide, including Europe, have faced a severe panzootic outbreak of the HPAI H5N1 virus, clade 2.3.4.4b (Koopmans et al., 2024). This outbreak has caused the death or culling of hundreds of millions of farmed and wild birds, making it one of the largest avian influenza outbreaks on record (CDC, 2024a). It has also led to substantial economic losses and severely disrupted poultry supply chains. (Banyard et al., 2024). The H5N1 subtype was first detected at a commercial goose farm in China in 1996 (Watanabe et al., 2013; M Tiwari et al., 2024) and later spread to a wide range of bird species (CDC, 2024a). Over time, the virus evolved, and by 2024, H5N1 clade 2.3.4.4b had developed into 16 genotypes, with the dominant G1 genotype being detected across multiple countries. This clade has exhibited an unprecedented range of host infections and pathogenicity, with infections reported in over 90 species of wild and domestic birds, as well as more than 199 mammalian species, including cats, foxes, minks, harbor seals and sea lions (Caserta et al., 2024). The virus has even reached polar regions, causing the death of a polar bear in the Arctic and affecting elephant and fur seals as well as penguins in Antarctica (Banyard et al., 2024). Particularly intriguing and worrying are the recent cases in dairy cattle, as bovine species were known to be poorly susceptible to IAV and were previously reported not susceptible to H5N1 (Sreenivasan et al., 2019). In 2024, however, H5N1 clade 2.3.4.4b was found to infect cattle a number of farms, with confirmed transmission to humans in four cases (CDC, 2024a; CDC, 2024b; Oguzie et al., 2024; Burrough et al., 2024). Since 1996, there have been occasional spillovers of H5N1 also to humans. These spillovers have only occurred when there was close contact at the avian-mammal-human interface. Additionally, there have been only a few reported cases of probable but not sustained human-to-human transmission. (CDC, 2024a; Ungchusak et al., 2005; Wang et al., 2008). Notably, on the 6th of September, CDC reported the case of a patient from Missouri, USA, positive for an H5 type IAV. This patient had no known immediate exposure to animals, and no transmission was detected among close contacts (CDC, 2024c). In 2024, a total of 15 human cases of H5 were documented in the USA. With the exception of one case in Missouri, all others were linked to contact with infected animals—four involving infected dairy cows and the rest involving infected poultry. Subjects infected by H5N1 from dairy cattle (hereafter referred to as Cow-H5N1) exhibited mild symptoms, primarily conjunctivitis, malaise, and low-grade fever (Uyeki et al., 2024; CDC, 2024a). Human infections with highly pathogenic avian influenza (HPAI) H5 viruses typically have high fatality rates, averaging around 50%. It remains unclear whether Cow-H5N1 viruses are inherently less pathogenic in humans compared to other HPAI strains, or if factors such as the route of infection and/or viral load contribute to the milder symptoms observed.What is certain is that the recent detection of HPAI H5N1 in dairy cattle represents a significant cross-species transmission, highlighting the virus adaptability and its ability to infect mammals, particularly domestic ruminants, across multiple farms. Although current influenza surveillance shows no unusual human influenza activity, the zoonotic potential of the currently circulating H5N1 remains a concern. The possibility of a new pandemic caused by this virus is, then, a subject of ongoing debate (Burki, 2024; Dye & Barclay, 2024; Koopmans et al., 2024; The Lancet, 2024; Zhai et al., 2024). The prospect of this virus acquiring mutations that enable efficient human-to-human transmission is especially alarming. However, we believe that H5N1 is unlikely to become pandemic at least in the near future. This perspective is grounded on three key points, which we will detail in the following sections:a) The virus has not yet demonstrated efficient airborne transmission.b) The virus still needs to acquire certain genetic traits known to facilitate widespread transmission to human populations.c) The chaos logistic map indicates a low probability for this virus to adapt to the human populations.Nonetheless, given the widespread nature of the current outbreaks, the risk of a future pandemic, while uncertain, cannot be entirely ruled out. Cow-H5N1 has not yet demonstrated efficient airborne transmissionThe detection of mammal-to-mammal transmission of avian-origin influenza viruses (AIV) remains rare and depends on both genetic and phenotypic adaptations to the new hosts. The H5N1 virus and its linea -Abstract Truncated-
microbiology