Abstract:Video-based assessment (VBA) is gaining traction as an adjunctive, and potentially alternative, method to more traditional assessments of surgical technical skills during residency training and may someday play a role in professional certification. 1 In this issue of JAMA Network Open , Ketel et al 2 report the use of a previously developed, video-based, minimally invasive esophagectomy (MIE) competency assessment tool (CAT) 3 to examine the association between the intraoperative technical quality of how MIE is performed at 15 Dutch hospitals and postoperative complications. Similar to the initial seminal work reporting an association of technical quality with better patient outcomes, the authors used masked reviewers with expertise in MIE and found that hospitals with better overall technical quality in the performance of the operation had lower intraoperative and severe postoperative complication rates and better performance during the anastomosis phase was associated with lower leak rates. 2 This important work supports the concept that superior technical skill is associated with better patient outcomes. 4 ,5 It also builds on prior work by suggesting that expertise within the team (rather than just the individual) may be similarly critical. The association between better performance during the creation of anastomosis phase and lower postoperative leak rates is particularly compelling because it suggests that experts can accurately identify technical quality during the most critical steps of a procedure. However, as with anything, the devil is in the details. Therefore, we must consider the nuances of these data to fully understand their meaning and how they might eventually be operationalized. For example, hospitals that performed in the highest quartile of MIE-CAT score had a significantly lower rate of severe postoperative complications compared with those in the lowest quartile (18.7% in the highest quartile vs 39.2% in the lowest quartile). We should exercise caution, however, in interpreting this association because many postoperative complications may be affected by numerous other relevant patient-, process-, and hospital-level factors above and beyond the technical quality of the intraoperative care delivered. Another important nuance is the stratification of performance into quartiles for the purposes of this analysis. While there is certainly precedent for using this type of stratification and it is often necessary for presenting data in a cohesive and interpretable manner, our natural tendency is to equate lower-ranked performance with worse outcomes. However, this type of oversimplification can be problematic because technical ability spans a range (rather than a static rank), and increments within that range may not necessarily translate into clinically meaningful differences. Furthermore, performance may be associated differently with different outcomes, some of which may or may not be expected to be directly associated with better performance. For instance, in this study, R0 resection, lymph node yield, and 30-day mortality were not clearly associated with hospital MIE-CAT performance. While intraoperative technical quality may not necessarily directly affect postoperative mortality, it might have been reasonable to expect an association with R0 resection and lymph node yield. Because they weren't, this finding begs the question of why intraoperative and postoperative complications were associated while these other outcomes were not. It may simply be that these findings are a reminder that the goal is not, and should not be, numeric performance alone but, rather, clinically relevant competence. Because skill level represents a spectrum and a variety of skill levels may achieve the same desired result, as VBA becomes more common and takes on a larger role in evaluating surgical competence, it will be imperative to continue to anchor technical skill (as measured with these types of tools) to clinically relevant patient outcomes. A critical challenge highlighted by this study is the relatively labor-intensive nature of creating footage and completing assessments as part of VBA. That the authors cite an unfeasible workload as the main reason they could only use 2 representative videos to create a hospital-level assessment speaks directly to this concern. While the smaller team sizes at the Dutch hospitals included in this study may have facilitated a limited number of videos providing a generalizable representation of each hospital's performance, we cannot know what we haven't seen. With only 30 total videos assessed from the 15 hospitals that treated the 970 patients included in the study, potential explanations for these findings may be that (1) the authors have identified a tool that generalizes perfectly (with minimal data) to all the surgical team members and patients underg -Abstract Truncated-

ANTIHYPERTENSIVE DRUG THERAPY IN CONSIDERATION OF CIRCADIAN BLOOD PRESSURE VARIATION *

Video-Based Performance Analysis in Pituitary Surgery - Part 2: Artificial Intelligence Assisted Surgical Coaching

Improvement in the Quality of Early Postoperative Course after Endoscopic Transsphenoidal Pituitary Surgery: Description of Surgical Technique and Outcome

The Impact of Operative Video Review and Annotation on Training in Endoscopic Pituitary Surgery: A Preclinical Randomised Controlled Study

Integrins and Actin Filaments: Reciprocal Regulation of Cell Adhesion and Signaling*

Automated Surgical Skill Assessment in Endoscopic Pituitary Surgery using Real-time Instrument Tracking on a High-fidelity Bench-top Phantom

Surgical Outcomes and Predictors of Visual Function Alterations after Transcranial Surgery for Large-to-Giant Pituitary Adenomas

Utility of Nasal Access Guides in Endoscopic Endonasal Skull Base Surgery: Assessment of Use during Cadaveric Dissection and Workflow Analysis in Surgery

[Introduction to obstetrical endocrinology. 23. Sex differentiation and hormones].

Kinematic metrics and surgeon experience in robotic cholecystectomies: a pilot study on breaking down technical performance

Prognostic indicators in pituitary adenoma surgery: a comprehensive analysis of surgical outcomes and complications

Zur Lokomotionsmechanik schwimmender Dipterenpuppen

The Impact of Surgical Telementoring on Reducing the Complication Rate in Endoscopic Endonasal Surgery of the Skull Base

Video-Based Assessment of Surgical Quality

Novel workflow analysis of robot-assisted hysterectomy through objective performance indicators: a pilot study

Endoscopic Endonasal Pituitary Adenomas Surgery: the Surgical Experience of 178 Consecutive Patients and Learning Curve of Two Neurosurgeons

PitVis-2023 Challenge: Workflow Recognition in videos of Endoscopic Pituitary Surgery

A comparative analysis of video-based surgical assessment: is evaluation of the entire critical portion of the operation necessary?

[Effect of epirubicin on the heart conduction system in patients with Hodgkin's disease].

Clinical and Operative Risk Factors Associated With Prolonged Length of Stay After Endoscopic Pituitary Adenoma Resection

Still-births and neonatal deaths in the Philippine General Hospital after liberation (April 5, 1945 to April 4, 1946).