Abstract:Background Surgical education lacks a standardized, proficiency-based approach to evaluation and feedback. Objective To assess the implementation and reception (ie, feasibility) of an automated, standardized, longitudinal surgical skill assessment and feedback system, and identify baseline trainee (resident and fellow) characteristics associated with achieving proficiency in robotic surgery while learning robotic-assisted laparoscopic prostatectomy. Design, setting, and participants A quality improvement study assessing a pilot of a surgical experience tracking program was conducted over 1 yr. Participants were six fellows, eight residents, and nine attending surgeons at a tertiary cancer center. Intervention Trainees underwent baseline self-assessment. After each surgery, an evaluation was completed independently by the trainee and attending surgeons. Performance was rated on a five-point anchored Likert scale (trainees were considered "proficient" when attending surgeons' rating was ≥4). Technical skills were assessed using the Global Evaluative Assessment of Robotic Skills (GEARS) and Prostatectomy Assessment and Competency Evaluation (PACE). Outcome measurements and statistical analysis Program success and utility were assessed by evaluating completion rates, evaluation completion times, and concordance rates between attending and trainee surgeons, and exit surveys. Baseline characteristics were assessed to determine associations with achieving proficiency. Results and limitations Completion rates for trainees and attending surgeons were 72% and 77%, respectively. Fellows performed more steps/cases than residents (median [interquartile range]: 5 [3–7] and 3 [2–4], respectively; p < 0.01). Prior completion of robotics or laparoscopic skill courses and surgical experience measures were associated with achieving proficiency in multiple surgical steps and GEARS domains. Interclass correlation coefficients on individual components were 0.27–0.47 on GEARS domains. Conclusions An automated surgical experience tracker with structured, longitudinal evaluation and feedback can be implemented with good participation and minimal participant time commitment, and can guide curricular development in a proficiency-based education program by identifying modifiable factors associated with proficiency, individualizing education, and identifying improvement areas within the education program. Patient summary An automated, standardized, longitudinal surgical skill assessment and feedback system can be implemented successfully in surgical education settings and used to inform education plans and predict trainee proficiency.

Development and evaluation of a societal core robotic surgery accreditation curriculum for the UK

Implementation and Validation of an Automated, Longitudinal Robotic Surgical Evaluation and Feedback Program at a High-volume Center and Impact on Training

An over-view of robot assisted surgery curricula and the status of their validation

Content and construct validation of a robotic surgery curriculum using an electromagnetic instrument tracker

A systematic review of robotic surgery curricula using a contemporary educational framework

Conception and prospective multicentric validation of a Robotic Surgery Training Curriculum (RoSTraC) for surgical residents: from simulation via laboratory training to integration into the operation room

Best Practices for Robotic Surgery Training and Credentialing

Feasibility, effectiveness and transferability of a novel mastery-based virtual reality robotic training platform for general surgery residents

Development and validation of surgical training tool: cystectomy assessment and surgical evaluation (CASE) for robot-assisted radical cystectomy for men

Adapting to a Robotic Era: The Transferability of Open and Laparoscopic Skills to Robotic Surgery

A review of minimal access surgery provision and training within the United Kingdom

Competency in Robotic Surgery: Standard Setting for Robotic Suturing Using Objective Assessment and Expert Evaluation

Current Standards for Training in Robot-assisted Surgery and Endourology: A Systematic Review

Creation and validation of a novel low-cost dry lab for early resident training and assessment of robotic prostatectomy technical proficiency

IMRA/SRS Delphi consensus on international standards for common core components of robotic surgical training design

Objective Assessment of Robotic Surgical Technical Skill: A Systematic Review

A comprehensive review of robotic surgery curriculum and training for residents, fellows, and postgraduate surgical education

The current status of robotic colorectal surgery training programmes

The IDEAL framework for surgical robotics: development, comparative evaluation and long-term monitoring

Development and validation of a tool for non-technical skills evaluation in robotic surgery-the ICARS system

What are clinically relevant performance metrics in robotic surgery? A systematic review of the literature