Youth Screen Media Activity Patterns and Associations with Behavioral Developmental Measures and Resting-State Brain Functional Connections
Kunru Song,Jialin Zhang,Nan Zhou,Yu Fu,Bowen Zou,Linxuan Xu,Ziliang Wang,Xin Li,Yihong Zhao,Marc N. Potenza,Xiaoyi Fang,Jintao Zhang
DOI: https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.4141354
2022-01-01
SSRN Electronic Journal
Abstract:Background: Screen media activity (SMA) consumes considerable time in youth’s lives, raising concerns about the effects it may have on youth development. Inconsistent findings generated recommendations that disentangling mixed associations between youth’s SMA and developmental measures should move beyond overall screen time and consider types and patterns of SMA. We aimed to identify reliable and generalizable SMA patterns among youth and examine their associations with behavioral developmental measures and developing brain function.Methods: Three waves of Adolescent Brain and Cognitive Development (ABCD) data were examined. The Lifespan Human Connectome Project in Development (HCP-D) was interrogated as an independent sample. ABCD participants included 11,878 children at baseline. HCP-D participants included 652 children and adolescents. Youth-reported SMA and behavioral developmental measures (neurocognitive performance, behavioral problems, prodromal psychotic symptoms, impulsivity, and sensitivities to punishment/reward) were assessed with validated instruments. We identified SMA patterns in the ABCD baseline data using K-means clustering and sensitivity analyses. The generalizability and stability of the identified SMA patterns were examined in HCP-D data and ABCD follow-up waves, respectively. Relationships were examined between SMA patterns and behavioral and brain (resting-state brain functional connections [RSFCs]) measures using linear-mixed-effect modelling with false-discovery-rate (FDR) correction.Findings SMA data from 11,817 children (Meanage= 119.0 months, SDage= 7.5; 6,159 (52.1%) boys) were examined, and 3,151 (26.7%) demonstrated a video-centric higher-frequency SMA pattern and 8,666 (73.3%) demonstrated a lower-frequency pattern. The SMA patterns were validated in similarly-aged HCP-D youth. Compared to the lower-frequency-SMA-pattern group, the video-centric-higher-frequency-SMA-pattern group showed poorer neurocognitive performance (Beta=-0.12, 95%CI, [-0.08, -0.16], FDR-corrected p <.001), more total behavioral problems (Beta=0.13, 95%CI, [0.09, 0.18], FDR-corrected p <.001), and more severe prodromal psychotic symptoms (Beta=0.31, 95%CI, [0.27, 0.36], FDR-corrected p <.001). The video-centric-higher-frequency-SMA-pattern group demonstrated higher impulsivity, more sensitivity to punishment/reward and altered RSFCs among brain areas implicated previously in cognitive processes. Most behavioral associations persisted with age in ABCD follow-up data. A social-communication-centric SMA pattern was observed in HCP-D adolescents.Interpretation: Video-centric SMA patterns are reliable and generalizable during late childhood. A higher-frequency-video-entertainment-SMA-pattern group showed altered RSFCs and poorer developmental measures that persisted longitudinally. The findings suggest public health strategies aiming to decrease excessive time spent by children on video-entertainment-related SMA are needed. Further studies are needed to examine potential video-centric/social-centric SMA bifurcation to understand dynamic changes and trajectories of SMA patterns and related outcomes developmentally.Funding: National Science Foundation of China, Children and Screens, National Institutes of Health.Declaration of Interest: The authors declared that there were no competing interests that exist.Ethical Approval: For the Adolescent Brain Cognitive Development study, the institutional review boards of the University of California, San Diego (IRB# 160091) and the local study sites (N = 22) approved the study protocol. Children provided verbal assent and written informed consent was obtained from their parents and/ or caregivers. For the Lifespan Human Connectome Projects in Development study, participants under 18 years are accompanied by a parent or legal guardian who provides informed, written permission for their child's participation and participants above 18 years provided written informed consent by themselves. All data used here were publicly available through the NDA data base (http://nda.nih.gov/abcd).