How long-term changes in neighborhood and school racial composition shape children's behavior problems

Jennifer Candipan,Nicole L Hair,Katrina M Walsemann

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.socscimed.2024.117161

Abstract:Relatively few neighborhood-focused studies explicitly model the relationship between neighborhood change- i.e., racial change within a neighborhood-and individual mental health, instead focusing on the current composition of the neighborhood or on the outcomes of individuals that switch neighborhood contexts via moves. Further, while neighborhoods and schools are interconnected, researchers tend to focus on only one of these contexts in their work. Combining family and student data from the Panel Study of Income Dynamics (PSID) with multiple waves of neighborhood and school administrative data, our study extends current scholarship in this area by explicitly focusing on the relationship between exposure to neighborhood and school racial change-i.e., change occurring within the neighborhood or school in the prior decade-and the behavior problems of current students. We further analyze how associations vary: 1) by student race; 2) between newcomers to the neighborhood and those that lived in the neighborhood as it underwent demographic change; 3) and in neighborhoods with higher proportions of same-race residents. Our findings suggest that the relationship between local neighborhood contexts and the behavioral problems of children is nuanced and depends on the racial trajectories-change or stability-of neighborhoods, schools, and the interaction of both. Compared to longer-term residents, White newcomers tended to have more behavioral problems across racially changing and stable neighborhoods alike, regardless of the racial trajectories observed in the local school. Our results align with past work documenting the protective effect of same-race peers for Black children. Conversely, we find White students exhibit greater behavioral problems in settings with very high proportions of same-race peers, particularly in neighborhoods and schools that are simultaneously becoming increasingly racially isolated.