Advances in the Soft Anatomy and Skeletal Microstructures of Cambrian Hyoliths in China and Their Implications for Lophotrochozoan Evolution
Fan Liu,Zhifei Zhang,Christian B. Skovsted
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1360/tb-2020-1433
2021-01-01
Chinese Science Bulletin (Chinese Version)
Abstract:Hyolitha is an extinct enigmatic marine invertebrate group that ranges throughout the Palaeozoic, from the early Cambrian to the endPermian mass extinction. As one of the most dominant benthic animals in Cambrian and Ordovician strata, hyoliths are common components of both small shelly fossil assemblages from carbonates and Konservat Lagerstatten where their soft tissues are preserved in exquisite detail. Despite this wealth of specimens, the biological affinity and life mode of hyoliths are still unclear and have long been controversial. However, based on the abundant and diverse record of Cambrian fossil hyoliths found in North America, Greenland, Australia and China, considerable advances have recently been made. Discoveries from the Cambrian of China reported herein play a significant role in revealing the morphology of hyoliths, in particular, from the famous exceptionally preserved Chengjiang and Guanshan biotas where delicate anatomical details are fossilized, and the well-known Small Shelly Fossil assemblages of the Shuijingtuo and Xinji Formations, which preserve shell microstructures. These new fossil discoveries have significant implications for interpreting the shell morphology, ultrastructure, soft part anatomy, life mode, and as discussed here, the biological affinity of hyoliths. The new data and interpretations provide novel ideas on the origin and early evolution of these shell-bearing animals during the Cambrian explosion, with particular implications on the evolutionary history of lophotrochozoans. With a brief review and history of the group, the present paper summarizes the significant progress made regarding our knowledge of Cambrian hyoliths from China during the past decade, outlining new fossil evidence obtained from both the soft anatomy and shell microstructure. Through a series of techniques, such as scanning electron microscope (SEM), microtomography (micro-CT) and nondestructive Micro X-ray Fluorescence (mu-XRF), in addition to the more traditional observation under light microscopy, new internal anatomical structures of hyoliths from the Konservat-Lagerstatten of China, were revealed providing significant new evidence concerning the general reconstruction of hyolith anatomy, especially for the digestive system and feeding apparatus. Revision of the orthothecid genus Triplicatella from the Chengjiang biota, South China revealed a exquisitely preserved tuft-like arrangement of feeding tentacles extending from the shell and a spiral-loop folded gut. Compared with members of the lophophorates that possess a distinctly shaped filter-feeding ciliated lophophore (such as brachiopods), the feeding organ in orthothecids instead consists of a fan-shaped tuft of tentacles that could extend freely outside the operculum with a flexible pharynx. This suggests a different physiological structure and feeding mechanism when compared with the lophophore. The morphology of the feeding apparatus, combined with the morphology of the flat venter, suggest that Triplicatella should be interpreted as a benthic deposit feeder, an interpretation that may also apply to the ancestors of orthothecids. This new discovery of a tentacular apparatus optimized for deposit feeding in hyoliths indicates that tentacle-bearing animals in the early Cambrian were more complex than previously assumed. Recent investigations of hyolith shell microstructures from the Xinji Formation of North China show an aragonitic lamellar shell structure composed of foliated aragonite, which appears to be highly similar to the shell structure of the earliest biomineralized molluscs. These discoveries promote a closer relationship between hyoliths and molluscs rather than the lophophorates. Despite these significant revelations, resolving the evolution of `shells' and `multipartite scleritomes' among the diverse lophotrochozoans is challenging. Elucidating the origin and early evolution of the clade, combined with the development of a credible reconstruction of the anatomy and shell ultrastructure of the earliest members of the clade, will be the most crucial element in solving the biological affinity of hyoliths and further providing a systematic overhaul of lophotrochozoans. Hyoliths, as one of the oldest tubular-living animal groups, are of great value for understanding the origin and taxonomic diversification of lophotrochozoans in the early Cambrian. Additional data on the ultrastructure, anatomy and palaeoecology of hyoliths needs to be comprehensively explored, and more comparative studies between hyoliths and other tube-forming taxa from the EdiacaranCambrian transition will also be required in the future to illuminate the origins of the lophotrochozoans.