The cover. The list.
T. B. Cole
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1001/jama.2010.1437
2010-10-20
Abstract:THE ARTIST GEORGES SCHREIBER WAS BORN IN BRUSsels, Belgium, in 1904. He studied at the Arts and Crafts School in Elberfeld, Germany, and at the Academies of Fine Art in Berlin and Düsseldorf. Schreiber then supplemented his academic training with a tour of art museums and painters’ studios in London, Paris, Rome, and Florence. In 1925 he found work as a freelance illustrator for German newspapers. Three years later he traveled to the United States and began to submit drawings and cartoons to The New York Times and New York Post. Schreiber settled permanently in the United States in 1933 and became a regular contributor to Vanity Fair, Pictorial Review, Stage, Bookman, The New Yorker, and Esquire. In 1936 Schreiber enrolled in the Federal Art Project and spent the next three years traveling the country, making lithographs to represent each of the 48 US states. One of these lithographs, In Tennessee, is a view of two mules pulling a wagon at dusk, and another, In Texas, shows a cowboy roping wild mustangs. In the 1930s, the United States had a large rural population whose way of life was under stress as a result of widespread drought and unemployment. Viewers of Schreiber’s lithographs were comforted by his images of ordinary men and women working to carry on the traditions of rural life. All the pictures sold at exhibition, and Schreiber was able to afford a summer home on Martha’s Vineyard, Massachusetts. His neighbor and friend on the island was the artist Thomas Hart Benton. When the United States declared war on Japan, Germany, and Italy in 1941, many artists, including Schreiber, volunteered for duty. In 1943 he and Benton shared quarters aboard a submarine and made paintings of life at sea. Schreiber also painted propaganda posters with titles such as Keep Them Flying, Back the Attack, and Fire Away. The List (cover) is a picture about death during wartime. In this image, eight women and girls are reading a piece of paper stuck to a branch of a tree. The writing on the paper is obscured by glare from a strong light source, but the title of the artwork suggests that it is a list of names. Two of the women have apparently read a name on the list that brought them to tears. During the year before The List was painted, the German army overran Belgium, where Schreiber was born, and much of the European continent. More than 6000 men died in combat in the Battle of Belgium, another 2000 died in captivity, and more than 15 000 were wounded. The numbers of Belgian casualties may seem small in relation to the millions of men, women, and children who ultimately died in World War II, but as Schreiber’s picture tells, each of the names of dead and wounded soldiers had meaning for the survivors. The women and girls are dressed simply in thick clothing against the cold. Their features and dress are generic. The list is hung so low on the tree that they have to crouch to read it, like actors in a play. The darkness of an approaching storm throws sharp shadows on their faces, indicating that trouble is coming. Generic features, theatrical staging, and strong lighting are characteristic of World War II poster art. The women and girls clutch one another for support, facing the storm, suggesting that unity is the source of their strength. The world war affected artists and their work in different ways. Benton, for example, felt compelled to shock his audience by exposing the enemy’s brutality. Schreiber, on the other hand, saw pathos in human suffering. His empathy for ordinary people confronted with disaster continued even after the war ended in 1945. On March 25, 1947, a coal dust explosion in a mine near the town of Centralia, Illinois, killed 111 men. This disaster caught the attention of artists who were concerned about the working conditions in the mines. The American folksinger Woody Guthrie wrote and recorded The Dying Miner, in memory of Joe Ballantini, Fred Gutzler, Joe Bryant, and the other men who died in the explosion. Schreiber commemorated the disaster by adapting The List. In short, he turned it around. The 1947 version of The List, subtitled Widows of Centralia, Ill., depicts women and girls facing a list stuck to a tree on the right side of the picture rather than the left. Otherwise, the differences in the two images are minor, and the message is the same: naming the dead identifies them as individuals, and the relationships these individuals had with others during their lives were severed by the fact of their deaths. A simple list of names can communicate the finality of death more effectively than a tally of numbers on a casualty report. Only by naming the dead can the living begin to grieve.