"My mom is a fighter": A qualitative analysis of the use of combat metaphors in intensive care unit clinician notes
Shannen Kim,Hunter Mills,Teva Brender,Samuel McGowan,Eric Widera,Allyson C Chapman,Krista L Harrison,Sei Lee,Alex K Smith,David Bamman,Oksana Gologorskaya,Julien Cobert
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.chest.2024.07.178
IF: 9.6
2024-08-26
Chest
Abstract:Background: A metaphor conceptualizes one, typically abstract, experience in terms of another, more concrete, experience with the goal of making it easier to understand. Even though combat metaphors have been well-described in some health contexts, they have not been well-characterized in the setting of critical illness. Research question: How do clinicians use combat metaphors when describing critically ill patients and families in the electronic health record? Study design and methods: We included notes written about patients >=18 years admitted to ICUs within a large hospital system from 2012-2020. We developed a lexicon of combat words, and isolated note segments that contained any combat mentions. Combat mentions were systematically defined as a metaphor or not across two coders. Among combat metaphors, we used a grounded theory approach to construct a conceptual framework around their use. Results: Across 6,404 combat-related mentions, 5,970 were defined as metaphors (Cohen's kappa 0.84). The most common metaphors were "bout" (26.2% of isolated segments), "combat" (18.5%), "confront" (17.8%) and "struggle" (17.5%). We present a conceptual framework highlighting how combat metaphors can present as identity ("mom is a fighter") and process constructs ("struggling to breathe"). Identity constructs were usually framed around: (1) hope, (2) internal strength, and/or (3) contextualization of current illness based on prior experiences. Process constructs were used to describe: (1) "fighting for" (e.g. working toward) a goal, (2) "fighting against" an unwanted force, or (3) experiencing internal turmoil. Interpretation: We provide a novel conceptual framework around the use of combat metaphors in the ICU. Further studies are needed to understand intentionality behind their use and how they impact clinician behaviors and patient/caregiver emotional responses.