Abstract:ABSTRACT Background Front-of-pack labeling (FOPL) has been implemented in several countries in the Americas, with Chile being the first to introduce a mandatory ‘high in’ warning FOPL in 2016. The Pan American Health Organization (PAHO) food classification criteria, considered a best practice for FOPL regulations, has been adopted by Mexico, Argentina, and Colombia. Canada’s FOPL regulations were recently approved and will take effect in January 2026, but it is unknown how these regulations compare to FOPL regulations that have already been implemented in other parts of the region. Objectives To compare the Canadian criteria for FOPL regulations with other FOPL criteria implemented in the Americas, and to determine their ability to identify ultra-processed products (UPPs). Methods Packaged foods and beverages (n=17,094) from the University of Toronto’s Food Label Information and Price (FLIP) 2017 database were analyzed using three FOPL criteria (Canadian, Chilean and PAHO criteria) and the NOVA classification system. The proportions of products that would be subject to displaying a ‘high in/excess’ FOPL and UPPs that would not be subject to FOPL regulations were examined under each system’s criteria. Agreement patterns were modeled using a nested sequence of hierarchical Poisson log-linear models. The Wald statistics for homogeneity were used to test whether proportional distributions differ significantly. Results Under the Canadian, Chilean and PAHO criteria, 54.4%, 68.4%, and 81.3% of packaged products would be required to display a ‘high in/excess’ FOPL, respectively. Disagreements between the Chilean and the Canadian criteria with PAHO’s were significant, but the greatest disagreement was between the Canadian and PAHO criteria. According to the Canadian, Chilean, and PAHO criteria, 33.4%, 18.4%, 2.3% of UPPs would not be subject to FOPL regulations, respectively. Conclusions A significant proportion of products that should be subject to FOPL regulations according to the PAHO criteria would not be regulated under Chilean and Canadian criteria, resulting in high proportion of UPPs that would not be subject to FOPL regulations. The Canadian FOPL criteria are the most lenient, with the highest proportion of UPPs that would not display a FOPL. Results can inform improvements for FOPL regulations in Canada, Chile and other countries.

Simulated use of thresholds for precautionary allergen labeling: Impact on prevalence and risk

Precautionary Allergen Labeling: Avoidance for All?

Time to ACT-UP: Update on precautionary allergen labelling (PAL)

Assessing Precautionary Allergen Labeling Management in China: A Comprehensive Analysis of Unintended Allergen Presence and VITAL® 3.0 Evaluation

Peanut Can Be Used as a Reference Allergen for Hazard Characterization in Food Allergen Risk Management: A Rapid Evidence Assessment and Meta-Analysis

Utility of food allergy thresholds

Allergen labelling: Current practice and improvement from a communication perspective

Precautionary Allergen Labelling in Serbia: Market Audit and Consumers' Perception

Comparative Performance of 4 Penicillin-Allergy Prediction Strategies in a Large Cohort

High anxiety and health-related quality of life in families with children with food allergy during coronavirus disease 2019

Identifying thresholds of reaction for different foods

Concerns Arise: Wheat Allergy Risk in Pre-packaged Food Products from China

Threshold of Reactivity and Tolerance to Precautionary Allergen-Labelled Biscuits of Baked Milk- and Egg-Allergic Children

Food Allergy: Labelling and exposure risks

Comparing Canada's 2018 proposed and 2022 final front-of-pack labelling regulations using generic food composition data and a nationally representative dietary intake survey

Comparing the Canadian front-of-pack labeling regulations with other mandatory approaches in the Americas and their ability to identify ultra-processed products

567. The Quality & Management of Penicillin Allergy Labels in a Pediatric Birth Cohort

An overview of hidden food allergens: need for change to the priority food allergen lists?

The efficacy of 'high in' warning labels, health star and traffic light front-of-package labelling: an online randomised control trial

Perspectives in precautionary allergen labelling of prepackaged foods after the FAO/WHO consultation

The Risk Reduction of Accidental Exposure-Related Systemic Allergic Reactions Extrapolated Based on Food Challenge Data After 1 Year of Peanut Oral Immunotherapy