PUBLIC OPINIONRESEARCH AND SUPPORT FOR THE IRAQ WAR ADAMJ
P. Feaver,Christopher Gelpi
Abstract:Professors Peter Feaver, Christopher Gelpi, and Jason Reifler’s theory of the determinants of public support for war has received a great deal of attention among academics, journalists, and policymakers. They argue that support for war hinges on initial support for military action and the belief in the success of the war. In this review, we take a critical and constructive view of their work, focusing on methodological concerns. We discuss the dependent variable used by the authors—individual casualty tolerance—and argue that it is an insufficient measure of war support. We also make the case that their independent variables of interest—initial support for war and evaluation of war success—may, in fact, be best understood as indicators of latent support for the war more generally. Finally, we discuss the need for more research into the determinants of support for war, focusing on core values and elite rhetoric as potential variables for continued and future study. The question of whether politicians, particularly the president, attend to public opinion when crafting foreign policy has long intrigued social scientists. For many years, conventional wisdom suggested that the public lacked the sophistication needed to form coherent foreign policy attitudes. From this point of view politicians should—and do—ignore public opinion. More recently, however, scholars have countered this perspective, producing considerable evidence that the public holds consistent opinions on foreign ADAM J. BERINSKY is an Associate Professor in the Department of Political Science, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge, MA 02139. JAMES N. DRUCKMAN is an Associate Professor in the Department of Political Science, Northwestern University, Evanston, IL 60208, USA. We thank Jason Reifler and Christopher Gelpi for making their questionnaires available to us and Chris Federico for providing us with the data from his co-authored article. We thank the anonymous reviewers, Sean Aday, Matthew Baum, Paul Brewer, Sunshine Hillygus, Ron Krebs, Rose McDermott, Peter Miller, Jason Reifler, Mark Schulman, and John Sides for helpful advice, and Toby Bolsen and Matt Gusella for research assistance. Address correspondence to James N. Druckman, e-mail: druckman@northwestern.edu Public Opinion Quarterly Advance Access published February 18, 2007