Huxley as Educator: A Reappraisal

D. Layton
DOI: https://doi.org/10.2307/367984
History of Education Quarterly
Abstract:Since the completion of his Ph.D. thesis in 1955, Dr. Bibby has virtually made the life and work of T. H. Huxley his personal academic territory. The results of his researches are embodied in three books, excluding that now under review, together with almost a score of papers. One by one the multiple facets of Huxley's singularly productive, frequently turbulent and unquestionably influential career have been explored: the Huxley-Wilberforce debate; Huxley and the South London Working Men's College; Huxley and the London School Board; Huxley on Technical Education; Huxley on Medical Education; Huxley's idea of a university. As Dr. Bibby informs his readers in a disarmingly immodest statement, these published papers "provide between them such a range of references to original sources as to open virtually all paths to further study of T. H. Huxley as educator." The popular image of Thomas Henry Huxley is probably that of a nineteenth century scholastic Moses leading a coeducational army of students and teachers out of a pedagogic wilderness into the promised land wherein curricula overflow with fructifying scientific knowledge. Huxley's Mosaic qualities are well illustrated in the long introductory essay which Dr. Bibby contributes. Trenchantly outspoken, an abominator of cant and humbug, Huxley is portrayed as the unswerving champion of empirical rationalism, ever ready to do battle for the sacred cause. As another writer on Huxley has recorded, "Exhilarated by the smell of war and never lacking self-assurance, he would take on hordes of mighty theologians, recklessly allowing them the choice of weapons and place of combat." (1) And not theologians only. Civic worthies, pillars of the educational establishment, guardians of the Ci ty Guilds were all, as the occasion required, consigned to the lists and charged with vigour. This bellicose image was by no means uncongenial to Huxley himself; even towards the close of his life, when racked by ill-health, he could still write, reverting now to a nautical metaphor, that "this old hulk is ready to be towed out into line of battle" on the issue of university reform. (2) As he championed under-privileged academic studies, in particular the natural sciences, so also he supported those social groups which he regarded as in need of educational liberation. The most notable of these were women and the children of the labouring poor, each consti tuting a substantial reservoir of untapped ability. In relation to the latter, as Dr. Bibby reminds his readers, Huxley coined a phrase which was to pass into the language, with his
What problem does this paper attempt to address?