Expert Consensus on a Set of Outcomes to Assess the Effectiveness of Biologic Treatment in Psoriatic Arthritis: The MERECES Study
Juan D Cañete,Joan M Nolla,Ruben Queiro,Miguel J Rodríguez,Miguel Ruiz,Luis Lizán,MERECES Working Group,Isabel Belinchón,Eugenio Chamizo,Jesús Babio,Raquel Almodóvar,Tamara Del Río,José Luis Poveda,Ángel Abad,Carlos Mur,Pablo de la Cueva,Cristina Fernández-Carballido,Beatriz Joven,José A Pinto,Ana Lozano,Leticia León,José Soto,Eva Galíndez,Mari L García-Vivar,Ana Ruibal,Natalia Palmou,Raúl Veroz,Esteban Rubio,José L Álvarez-Vega,Elena Alonso,Jesús Marzo,Laura Garrido,Lola Fabregas,Álvaro García-Martos,María C Ortega,Consuelo Díaz,Juan C Nieto,Carmen Torres,Pepe Pérez-Venegas,Jesús Sanz,Pedro Zarco,Santiago Muñoz,Txaro García-Vicuña,Carlos García-Porrúa,Francisco J Meceiras,Carolina Álvarez-Castro,José A Hernández-Beriain,Beatriz González,Mireia Moreno,Agustí Sellas,Julio Ramírez,Ana Urruticoechea,Andrés Ponce,Carlos Feced,Angels Martínez-Ferrer,Nagore Fernández-Llanio,Anna Martínez-Cristóbal,Cristina Campos,Arantxa Conesa,Enrique Batlle,Francisca Sivera,Vega Jovaní,Enrique Judez,Manuel Moreno,Fernando Rodríguez-Martínez,Ana María Laiz,Lourdes Mateo,Manel Pujol,Juan C Torre,Pablo Coto,Jaume Notario,Mercé García-Font,Antonio J Chaves,Conrad Pujol,Lluis Puig,Esteban Daudén,José L Sánchez-Carazo,Gregorio Carretero,José L López-Estebaranz,Anna López-Ferrer,Jose-Juan Pereyra-Rodriguez,Lourdes Rodríguez-Fernández,José M Carrascosa,Pedro Herranz,Ricardo Ruiz-Villaverde,Ana Turrión,Andrea M Cuervo,Carlos A Montilla,Concepción Delgado,Deseada Palma,José F García-Llorente,José L Rosales,José M Senabre,Juan J Lerma,María J Moreno,María López-Lasanta,María R Oliva,María T Navío,Patricia Tejón,Santos Castañeda,Sara Alonso-Castro,Senen González-Suárez,Vicente Torrente,Rosa García-Portales,Jorge Cancio,Victoria Navarro,Julio A Medina,Sergio Rodríguez-Montero,Pilar Ahijado,Azucena Hernández,Cruz Fernández-Espartero,José Antonio Mosquera,Delia Reina,Antonio García,Alejandra López,Ana Uceda,Joaquín Belzunegui
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3899/jrheum.191056
2020-11-01
Abstract:Objective: To reach a consensus on the instruments to be used in clinical practice to evaluate the effectiveness of biological disease-modifying antirheumatic drug (bDMARD) treatment in patients with psoriatic arthritis (PsA) in the short to medium term (3-6 mos), and to establish the minimum health outcomes for treatment continuation. Methods: A 2-round Delphi questionnaire was developed based on both the information gathered in the literature review and 4 discussion groups. The suitability and feasibility of the proposed sets of instruments were assessed on a 7-point Likert scale. Consensus was established when at least 75% of healthcare professionals (HCP) reached agreement. To define a minimum health outcome to continue treatment, a combination of 4 disease activity states and 3 health-related quality of life states were defined for 3 hypothetical patient profiles. HCP were given a dichotomous choice (yes/no) to respond to whether they would continue treatment in each case. Results: The second round was completed by 106 HCP. Consensus was reached on the use of (1) Disease Activity in Psoriatic Arthritis + Psoriatic Arthritis Impact of Disease (PsAID12) or minimal disease activity + PsAID12 + C-reactive protein, in peripheral PsA; and (2) Ankylosing Spondylitis Disease Activity Score + PsAID12, in axial PsA. Health outcomes considered sufficient to continue treatment were stricter for bDMARD-naive patients than for patients who failed several bDMARD. Conclusion: To the best of our knowledge, this is the first multidisciplinary consensus on a set of outcomes for the evaluation of bDMARD effectiveness in PsA, in routine clinical practice.