Abstract:Rumination is a symptom of depression that refers to intense, distraction-resistant thinking. Although rumination is widely considered maladaptive, the analytical rumination hypothesis (ARH) proposes that rumination is an adaptive cognitive process where depression first promotes rumination on the causes of problems (“causal analysis”), which in turn promotes rumination on solving problems (“problem-solving analysis”). Effective problem-solving then feeds back to reduce depressive symptoms. To test this cyclical model, a scale with both problem-solving and causal analysis components is required. There are two candidates: (1) the widely used Ruminative Responses Scale (RRS); and (2) the Analytical Rumination Questionnaire (ARQ)—a new scale based on the ARH. These instruments were administered to five samples (Total N =1414) from two different cultures (Canada, Czech Republic) with different clinical statuses (nonclinical, hospitalized). Latent factor analysis of the ARQ supported the existence of both causal analysis and problem-solving analysis factors, making it suitable for testing ARH predictions. Using the ARQ, we found consistent support for the predicted covariance pattern between depression, causal analysis, and problem-solving analysis. However, we found no evidence that either of the RRS factors were related to problem-solving. Moreover, we were systematically unable to detect the predicted covariance pattern between depression and the RRS factors. We conclude that the ability to detect functional relationships between depression and rumination requires the researcher to consider both function (a correct hypothesis for how rumination and depression are adaptively related to each other) and form (valid measures of those constructs). Understanding rumination as a two-stage problem-solving process may help explain why most depressive episodes eventually resolve without treatment.

What Are You Ruminating About? The Development and Validation of a Content-Dependent Measure of Rumination

The Positive and Negative Rumination Scale: Development and Preliminary Validation

A Review of Rumination Research Abroad

The Brief State Rumination Inventory (BSRI): Validation and Psychometric Evaluation

Rumination Reconsidered: A Psychometric Analysis

The form and function of depressive rumination

A roadmap to rumination: A review of the definition, assessment, and conceptualization of this multifaceted construct

Positive beliefs about depressive rumination: Development and preliminary validation of a self-report scale

Modeling Effects of Rumination on Free Recall Using ACT‐R

Rumination in dementia and its relationship with depression, anxiety, and attentional biases

Development and validation of the anger rumination scale

Unpacking Rumination and Executive Control: A Network Perspective

On assessing trait rumination using the Ruminative Response Scale

An experiential avoidance conceptualization of depressive rumination: Three tests of the model

Mindfulness in Persons with Mild Dementia and Their Caregivers: Exploring Trait Rumination as a Clinical Outcome Measure

The subsystem mechanism of default mode network underlying rumination: A reproducible neuroimaging study

Distinguishing worry from rumination in older people: A preliminary investigation

Toward a Better Understanding of Who Is Likely to Be Susceptible to the Effects of Rumination on Obsessive–Compulsive Symptoms: An Explorative Analysis

Investigating the transdiagnostic potential of rumination in relation to Cluster B personality disorder symptoms

Rumination and Psychopathology: Are Anger and Depressive Rumination Differentially Associated With Internalizing and Externalizing Psychopathology?