Ecosystem Resilience Monitoring and Early Warning Using Earth Observation Data: Challenges and Outlook

Sebastian Bathiany,Robbin Bastiaansen,Ana Bastos,Lana Blaschke,Jelle Lever,Sina Loriani,Wanda De Keersmaecker,Wouter Dorigo,Milutin Milenković,Cornelius Senf,Taylor Smith,Jan Verbesselt,Niklas Boers
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10712-024-09833-z
2024-05-09
Surveys in Geophysics
Abstract:As the Earth system is exposed to large anthropogenic interferences, it becomes ever more important to assess the resilience of natural systems, i.e., their ability to recover from natural and human-induced perturbations. Several, often related, measures of resilience have been proposed and applied to modeled and observed data, often by different scientific communities. Focusing on terrestrial ecosystems as a key component of the Earth system, we review methods that can detect large perturbations (temporary excursions from a reference state as well as abrupt shifts to a new reference state) in spatio-temporal datasets, estimate the recovery rate after such perturbations, or assess resilience changes indirectly from stationary time series via indicators of critical slowing down. We present here a sequence of ideal methodological steps in the field of resilience science, and argue how to obtain a consistent and multi-faceted view on ecosystem or climate resilience from Earth observation (EO) data. While EO data offers unique potential to study ecosystem resilience globally at high spatial and temporal scale, we emphasize some important limitations, which are associated with the theoretical assumptions behind diagnostic methods and with the measurement process and pre-processing steps of EO data. The latter class of limitations include gaps in time series, the disparity of scales, and issues arising from aggregating time series from multiple sensors. Based on this assessment, we formulate specific recommendations to the EO community in order to improve the observational basis for ecosystem resilience research.
geochemistry & geophysics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The paper primarily explores how to use Earth Observation (EO) data to monitor ecosystem resilience and presents related challenges and prospects. Specifically, the paper aims to address the following key issues: 1. **Defining and Quantifying Resilience**: First, the paper discusses the diversity of the resilience concept and its application differences across various disciplines. It emphasizes the challenges in quantifying resilience, especially the issues encountered when applying theoretical concepts to actual Earth science systems. 2. **Methods for Assessing Ecosystem Resilience from Earth Observation Data**: The paper focuses on two methods to estimate the engineering resilience of ecosystems (i.e., recovery rate). One method involves detecting major disturbance events in time series and quantifying the recovery rate following these events. The other method infers the recovery rate from the natural variability of the system, which does not require specific major disturbance events. 3. **Limitations and Challenges of Earth Observation Data**: The paper points out several significant limitations when using Earth Observation data for resilience monitoring, including the incompleteness of time series, scale differences, and the integration of time series from different sensors. 4. **Future Opportunities and Challenges**: With the increasing availability of high-resolution Earth Observation data, the paper discusses the potential and challenges of using these big data resources to monitor vegetation resilience. It also mentions the technical and theoretical issues that need to be addressed to achieve this goal. In summary, the goal of this paper is to evaluate and improve methods for extracting ecosystem resilience information from Earth Observation data to better understand and predict ecosystem responses to human activities and natural disturbances.