Abstract:The morphology of multicellular organisms can be viewed as structures of three-dimensional bulges and dents of an otherwise nearly two-dimensional epithelial sheet. Morphogenesis is thus a process to stably form those physical distortions over time through differential cellular adhesion, contraction, and aggregation and through cellular changes in size, shape, and number. Such physical distortions may be hierarchically repeated with modifications, which is suggested by self-similar structures in organisms. Butterfly wings are nearly two-dimensional but contain three-dimensional bulges and dents that correspond to organizing centers for color pattern elements. Importantly, an eyespot and its corresponding parafocal element on a wing, constituting the border symmetry system, are self-similar. From this perspective, I review here the color pattern rules and several formal models that have been proposed, clarifying their relationships with the induction model for positional information. To reinforce the induction model, I propose the distortion hypothesis, in which dynamic epithelial distortion forces at organizing centers, such as the center of a presumptive eyespot, that are produced through changes in cell size spread to surrounding immature cells over distances as morphogenic signals in developing butterfly wings. The physical distortion forces open stretch-activated calcium channels that cause calcium signals in the cell and activate the expression of regulatory genes. These regulatory gene products initiate a cascade of structural genes that eventually produce eyespot black rings. Calcium waves also activate a process of genome duplication, resulting in an increase in cell size, as the ploidy hypothesis states. A new distortion of epithelial cells is induced at the center of a presumptive parafocal element through an increase in cell size, producing self-similarity of the eyespot and the parafocal element. The self-similar configuration of the border symmetry system further suggests the essence of morphogenesis as the DCG cycle: repeated sequential events of epithelial distortions (D), calcium waves (C), and gene expression changes (G). Future studies should examine these hypotheses and speculations that constitute the induction model in butterfly wings and the generality of the DCG cycle in other organisms.

On Pattern and Evolution

An adhesion code ensures robust pattern formation during tissue morphogenesis

Sequential pattern formation governed by signaling gradients

Pattern Specification in the Insect Embryo

Phyllotaxis, a model

Understanding the Principles of Pattern Formation Driven by Notch Signaling by Integrating Experiments and Theoretical Models

A Broad Dynamical Model for Pattern Formation by Lateral Inhibition

Morphogens in the evolution of size, shape and patterning

Switch and template pattern formation in a discrete reaction diffusion system inspired by the Drosophila eye

Pattern Formation and Eyespot Determination in Butterfly Wings

Self-Similarity, Distortion Waves, and the Essence of Morphogenesis: A Generalized View of Color Pattern Formation in Butterfly Wings

Closing the Loop on Morphogenesis: A Mathematical Model of Morphogenesis by Closed-Loop Reaction-Diffusion

The reaction-diffusion approach to morphogenesis

Dynamics of pattern formation and emergence of swarming in C. elegans

Adaptive walks in a gene network model of morphogenesis: insights into the Cambrian explosion

Pattern formation along signaling gradients driven by active droplet behaviour of cell groups

Growth regulation bringing modularity to morphogenesis of complex three-dimensional exoskeletons

Beyond the French Flag Model: Exploiting Spatial and Gene Regulatory Interactions for Positional Information

Body plan evolvability: The role of variability in gene regulatory networks

Reaction–Diffusion Systems and External Morphogen Gradients: The Two-Dimensional Case, with an Application to Skeletal Pattern Formation

Network Evolution of Body Plans