The macroeconomic effect of petroleum product price regulation in alleviating the crude oil price volatility

Liu, Yaqing

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10644-024-09631-y

2024-02-17

Economic Change and Restructuring

Abstract:China adopted a market-based pricing mechanism for petroleum products to improve the economic efficiency of resource allocation, thereby exposing its macroeconomy to higher shocks in world crude oil price volatility. To address the WCOP volatility, the price of petroleum products is subject to government regulations. However, the macroeconomic effects of PPP regulations are yet to be studied thoroughly. Accordingly, this study first quantifies the degree of PPP regulation using a "profit + cost" model, followed by the filtration of the macroeconomic impacts of fiscal and monetary policies and then analyzes the economic effects of PPP using an SVAR model. Furthermore, a counterfactual analysis is conducted to verify the results. It was found that PPP regulation could alleviate the shock of WCOP volatility on industrial value-added, finished fixed asset investment, and the producer price index. These findings provide a deeper understanding of the macroeconomic effects of PPP regulations and provide policymakers with new information on the necessity of PPP regulations.

economics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is the role of China's petroleum product price (PPP) regulation in mitigating the impact of world crude oil price (WCOP) fluctuations on the macro - economy. Specifically, the research aims to quantify the degree of PPP regulation and analyze its impact on macro - economic indicators such as industrial added value, completed fixed - asset investment, and the producer price index, thereby providing new information for policymakers regarding the necessity of PPP regulation.

### Background of the Paper and the Problem

- **Background**: Fluctuations in the world crude oil price (WCOP) have a negative impact on the macro - economy, such as causing investment delays or inefficient resource allocation. Since 1949, China has adopted various petroleum product price (PPP) regulation mechanisms, including the market - pricing mechanism. Although market pricing has improved the efficiency of resource allocation, it has also exposed China to higher risks of international market crude oil price fluctuations.
- **Problem**: In response to WCOP fluctuations, the Chinese government regulates PPP, but the macro - economic effects of this regulation have not been fully studied. Therefore, this paper aims to quantify the degree of PPP regulation and evaluate its impact on the macro - economy.

### Research Methods

1. **Quantifying the Degree of PPP Regulation**:
- Use the "cost + profit" model to calculate the unregulated PPP ($P_g$), and quantify the degree of regulation ($V_c$) by comparing the actually observed PPP ($P_t$) with the unregulated PPP.
- The formulas are as follows:
\[
P_{gt}=(1 + \gamma_t)\frac{P_n^g}{\alpha P_n^g+\beta P_n}\left(\frac{P_{ot}+R}{1}\right)+C_t
\]
\[
V_{ct}=P_t - P_{gt}
\]

2. **Filtering the Influence of Fiscal and Monetary Policies**:
- Use ordinary least squares (OLS) regression analysis to filter out the influence of fiscal and monetary policies from macro - economic indicators such as completed fixed - asset investment (INV), industrial added value (IVA), and the producer price index (PPI).
- The regression equations are as follows:
\[
\text{INV}_t=\beta_0+\beta_1\text{Expenditure}(t - 4)+\beta_2\text{M1}_{t - 3}+\beta_3t+\mu_t
\]
\[
\text{IVA}_t=\delta_0+\delta_1\text{Expenditure}(t - 4)+\delta_2\text{M1}_{t - 3}+\delta_3t+\epsilon_t
\]
\[
\text{PPI}_t=\phi_0+\phi_1\text{Expenditure}(t - 4)+\phi_2\text{M1}_{t - 10}+\phi_3t+\eta_t
\]

3. **SVAR Model**:
- Construct a structural vector autoregressive (SVAR) model to estimate the macro - economic effects of PPP regulation and verify the results through counterfactual analysis.

### Main Contributions

1. **Quantifying the Degree of PPP Regulation**: This paper is the first to use the "cost + profit" model to quantify the degree of PPP regulation.
2. **Filtering the Influence of Fiscal and Monetary Policies**: Through regression analysis, the influence of fiscal and monetary policies is separated from macro - economic indicators to ensure the accuracy of the evaluation.
3. **Providing New Explanations**: The research shows that PPP regulation plays an important role in mitigating the impact of WCOP fluctuations on the macro - economy, providing a theoretical basis for maintaining PPP regulation.

### Conclusion

The study finds that PPP regulation can effectively mitigate the impact of WCOP fluctuations on industrial added value, completed fixed - asset investment, and the producer price index.