Abstract:Background: Research has shown that patients' and practitioners' cultural orientations affect communication behaviors and interpretations in cross-cultural patient-practitioner interactions. Little is known about the effect of cultural orientations on assessment of communication behaviors in cross-cultural educational settings. The purpose of this study is to explore cultural orientation as a potential source of assessor idiosyncrasy or between-assessor variability in assessment of communication skills. More specifically, we explored if and how (expert) assessors' valuing of communication behaviours aligned with their cultural orientations (power-distance, masculinity-femininity, uncertainty avoidance, and individualism-collectivism). Methods: Twenty-five pharmacist-assessors watched 3 videotaped scenarios (patient-pharmacist interactions) and ranked each on a 5-point global rating scale. Videotaped scenarios demonstrated combinations of well-portrayed and borderline examples of instrumental and affective communication behaviours. We used stimulated recall and verbal protocol analysis to investigate assessors' interpretations and evaluations of communication behaviours. Uttered assessments of communication behaviours were coded as instrumental (task-oriented) or affective (socioemotional) and either positive or negative. Cultural orientations were measured using the Individual Cultural Values Scale. Correlations between cultural orientations and global scores, and frequencies of positive, negative, and total utterances of instrumental and affective behaviours were determined. Results: Correlations were found to be scenario specific. In videos with poor or good performance, no differences were found across cultural orientations. When borderline performance was demonstrated, high power-distance and masculinity were significantly associated with higher global ratings (r = .445, and .537 respectively, p < 0.05) as well as with fewer negative utterances regarding instrumental (task focused) behaviours (r = -.533 and - .529, respectively). Higher masculinity scores were furthermore associated with positive utterances of affective (socioemotional) behaviours (r = .441). Conclusions: Our findings thus confirm cultural orientation as a source of assessor idiosyncrasy and meaningful variations in interpretation of communication behaviours. Interestingly, expert assessors generally agreed on scenarios of good or poor performances but borderline performance was influenced by cultural orientation. Contrary to current practices of assessor and assessment instrument standardization, findings support the use of multiple assessors for patient-practitioner interactions and development of qualitative assessment tools to capture these varying, yet valid, interpretations of performance.

Behavioral assessment of communication competency and the prediction of cross-cultural adaptation

A study of cross-cultural effectiveness: Theoretical issues, practical applications

Psychological Availability Between Self-Initiated Expatriates and Host Country Nationals During Their Adjustment: the Moderating Role of Supportive Supervisor Relations

Effect of Biographical Variables on Employees' Adaptation to Intercultural Communication in a University of Technology

Facilitating Cross-Cultural Adaptation: A Meta-Analytic Review of Dispositional Predictors of Expatriate Adjustment

Measuring Cultural Competencies: The Development and Validation of a Revised Measure of Sociocultural Adaptation

You can take it with you: individual differences and expatriate effectiveness

Assessing the impact of cross-cultural communication competence on expatriate business operations in multinational corporations of a Sub-Saharan African context

What Matters More – Inherited Traits or Life Experiences? An Application of the Integrative Communication Theory in the Study of Cross-Cultural Adjustment and Assignment Satisfaction

Cross-Cultural Validation of Acculturation Measures: Expanding the East Asian Acculturation Framework for Global Applicability

Methods of Assessing Intercultural Competence for International Assignments: A Systematic Review of Reviews

Moscow on the Hudson: assessing expatriates' affective fit in host cultures with the intercultural communication affinity scale

Exploring the influence of cultural orientations on assessment of communication behaviours during patient-practitioner interactions

Guidelines for Cross-Cultural Communication Effectiveness

Impression Management and Cross-Cultural Adaption

Cross-Cultural Adaptation of the Communication Assessment Tool for Use in a Simulated Clinical Setting

Using Behavioral Skills Training to Teach Functional Assessment Interviewing, Cultural Responsiveness, and Empathic and Compassionate Care to Students of Applied Behavior Analysis

Cross-Cultural Adaptation of Hispanic Youth: A Study of Communication Patterns, Functional Fitness, and Psychological Health

Research note: the role of willingness to communicate in cross-cultural adaptation

Cross-Cultural Communication Theory

The cross-cultural adaptation of Chinese international students: an empirical study on sequential-mediated effects