Is breast feeding a likely cause of dental caries in young children?

L. Abbey

DOI: https://doi.org/10.14219/JADA.ARCHIVE.1979.0028

Abstract:i^ ^ d v isn rv boards o f organizations that advocate unrestricted, at-w ill breast feeding and notably La Leche League International have received calls from their members regarding recent reports o f “ nursing caries” in young children. It seem s that dentists w ho recognize the pattern have suggested that the mothers discontinue nursing as a means of prevent­ ing further decay. The mothers, o f course, want to take their dentist’s advice and yet it is against all that they believe to be best for their children. The syndrom e characterized by a rampant caries pattern beginning with the maxillary anterior teeth and eventually affecting the posterior teeth in a healthy, bottle-fed infant or toddler has been de­ scribed as “ nursing bottle m outh” by Fass1 and by others.2 T w o recent reports3,4 attribute a similar caries pattern in eight children to total breast feed­ ing. Is breast feeding also an etiologic agent in this caries pattern? In unrestricted breast feeding, a child, sleeping in the same bed or at least in the same room w ith the mother, nurses at w ill during the night; he suckles w hen necessary and sleeps betw een feedings. The m other’s breast is both the nourisher and the pac­ ifier. A t-w ill, unrestricted breast feeding allow s the mother and baby to obtain necessary rest, yet to m aintain bodily closeness and sufficient suck­ ling to ensure an adequate m ilk su pply and con­ tinued suppression of ovluation. If the mother is counting on breast feeding to delay her return to fertility, she has no alternative but to practice unrestricted breast feeding, includ­ ing at-w ill feedings throughout the night.5 It has been sh ow n 5 7 that suppression of ovulation as­ sociated with nursing cannot be achieved if suckl­ ing is discontinued for long periods (such as during the night) or is interrupted by supplem ental feed­ ings. The reports linking early caries patterns and atw ill nighttim e nursing propose that m ilk stagnates on and around the teeth w hen the child falls asleep. This, in turn, enhances plaque formation, becom ing a causative factor in the evolving caries pattern. From a physiologic view point, how ever, the scenario just described probably does not happen in the nursing infant. A dditionally , behavioral and epidem iologic studies suggest that nighttim e, unre­ stricted nursing is a desirable and natural part of total breast feeding. A t this tim e, evidence supports hum an breast feeding as the m ost sound practice, physiologically and psychologically, for infants and it w ould seem ill-advised to recom m end its discon­