Current controversies in vaccination: vaccine safety.
Y. Maldonado
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1001/JAMA.288.24.3155
2002-12-25
Abstract:VACCINATION IS RANKED AS ONE of the 10 greatest public health achievements of the last century and is the number one contribution to decreased global morbidity and mortality. Pediatric vaccinations have had the most profound impact of any intervention on increasing global child survival, accounting for 3 million pediatric lives saved annually. However, even in the 21st century, vaccinepreventable infectious diseases remain important causes of morbidity and mortality in many areas of the world. Globally, tetanus, measles, and pertussis are the main vaccine-preventable causes of death in children; septicemia and influenza-related pneumonia are among the top 10 causes of death in adults and children worldwide, including the United States. Although US pediatric vaccination rates remain high, there is a small but vocal antivaccine movement concerned about vaccine safety that may affect vaccination efforts in the United States and elsewhere. In adults, vaccinepreventable diseases result in $10 billion in health care costs and more than 30000 preventable deaths annually; however, vaccination rates among adults remain poor and recommended vaccine schedules for US adults are markedly underutilized. Extending the success of childhood immunization programs to adult populations is therefore a major public health challenge, and recent misconceptions regarding vaccine safety may affect adult immunization initiatives as well. The challenges of developing vaccines against agents of bioterrorism add an important and complex dimension to monitoring safety in vaccine development. Recommended Pediatric and Adult Vaccination Schedules The US organization that determines pediatric and adult immunization policy and guidelines is the Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices (ACIP), an advisory group to the US Public Health Service and the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC). The ACIP includes representation from pediatric and general medical organizations and community advocates. The American Academy of Pediatrics and the American Academy of Family Physicians also develop separate ongoing pediatric and adult immunization guidelines that harmonize with the ACIP recommendations. Current vaccines recommended for routine use by the ACIP for pediatric and adult use are outlined in BOX 1, although there are a number of other vaccines available for pediatric and adult use in special circumstances. The US Public Health Service and CDC are assisted in review of new vaccines and new indications for current vaccines by the National Vaccine Advisory Committee, which is composed of academic physicians, public health agencies, and community advocates. Another organization that is critical to development of vaccine policy is the US Food and Drug Administration (FDA), which provides oversight of safety and efficacy claims for new vaccines. Although the FDA is not primarily responsible for vaccine policy, it is the sole US agency responsible for licensure and specific indications for vaccines proposed for use in the United States. Whenever there has been probable or even possible evidence of unacceptable vaccine-related adverse events, these committees and agencies have acted in collaboration to minimize harm and to preserve the public health. Risks and Benefits Rates of vaccine-preventable illnesses in children have reached record low numbers (TABLE). The success of vaccination programs has led to proportionally more concerns regarding vaccine safety than concerns about vaccine-preventable diseases, which would likely become reestablished in the absence of continued vaccination programs. A small number of highly publicized claims, unsubstantiated by valid data, regarding vaccineadverseeventshas furtherheightened the suspicion that some or all vaccines may cause unacceptable adverse events. These suspicions have been bolstered by the lack of experience or exposure to most vaccine-preventable illnesses, such as diphtheria, measles, tetanus, poliomyelitis, or Haemophilus influenzae–related invasive diseases, which were major causes of death and disability only a few decades ago. All vaccines carry some risk of adverse reactions. The majority of adverse reactions to the routinely recommended vaccines are minor and are related to pain, erythema, or inflammation at the injection site. These local reactions are common and may occur in up to 50% of vaccinees. Systemic symptoms such as fever, headache, irritability, or diminished activity are less common; the frequency of systemic symptoms is vaccine-specific. Rarely, moderate to severe reactions to vaccines, such as febrile seizures and allergic reactions, occur at a frequency of 1