PR01.08 Simultaneous Multi-Cancer Detection and Tissue of Origin Prediction Via Targeted Bisulfite Sequencing of Plasma Cell-Free DNA
K. Kurtzman,G. Oxnard,E. Klein,M. Seiden,E. Hubbell,O. Venn,A. Jamshidi,N. Zhang,J. Beausang,S. Gross,E. Fung,J. Yecies,R. Shaknovich,A. Fields,M. Sekeres,D. Richards,P. Yu,A. Aravanis,A. -R. Hartman,M. Liu
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jtho.2020.10.085
IF: 20.121
2021-01-01
Journal of Thoracic Oncology
Abstract:A minimally invasive cell-free DNA (cfDNA) blood test detecting multiple cancers at earlier stages could decrease cancer mortality. In earlier discovery work, whole-genome bisulfite sequencing outperformed whole-genome and targeted sequencing approaches for multi-cancer detection across stages at high specificity. Here, multi-cancer detection and tissue-of-origin (TOO) prediction using bisulfite sequencing of plasma cfDNA to identify methylomic signatures was evaluated in preparation for clinical validation, utility, and implementation studies. In all, 6,689 participants (2,482 cancer [>50 cancers, all stages]; 4,207 non-cancer) were included in this prespecified substudy from the Circulating Cell-free Genome Atlas (CCGA) study (NCT02889978) and the STRIVE study (NCT03085888) - prospective, multi-center, observational, case-control studies with longitudinal follow-up. Plasma cfDNA was subjected to a targeted methylation sequencing assay using high-efficiency methylation chemistry to enrich for methylation targets, and a machine-learning classifier determined cancer status and predicted TOO. Observed methylation fragments characteristic of cancer and TOO (cancer “signals”) were combined across targeted regions and assigned a relative probability of cancer and of a specific TOO. Test performance was also assessed in a subgroup of participants with clinical suspicion of cancer but without pathologic diagnosis or treatment at the time of enrollment. Performance is reported at 99.3% specificity (95% confidence interval [CI], 98.3-99.8%) (ie, a combined false positive rate across all cancers of <1%—a level required for population-level screening). Across all cancers, stage I-III sensitivity was 43.9% (95% CI, 39.4-48.5%). Combined cancer detection sensitivity (95% CI) was 18% (13-25%) in stage I (n=185), 43% (35-51%) in stage II (n=166), 81% (73-87%) in stage III (n=134), and 93% (87-96%) in stage IV (n=148). TOO was predicted for 96% of all cancers detected; of these, TOO was correct in 93% of cases. Among participants enrolled with suspicion of cancer and subsequently confirmed to have cancer (n=75), cancer detection across all stages was 46.7% (35/75; 95% CI, 35.1-58.6%) and TOO prediction accuracy was 97.1% (34/35; 95% CI, 85.1-99.9%). None of the non-cancer participants in the subgroup (n=15) had a cancer signal (ie, specificity was 100%). Detection of multiple cancers across stages using methylation signatures in plasma cfDNA was achieved with a single, fixed, low, false positive rate, and simultaneously provided accurate TOO prediction. This targeted methylation assay is undergoing validation in preparation for prospective clinical investigation as a cancer detection diagnostic.