Cross-Cultural Comparison in the Emotional Responses Elicited by Wine Odors
A. Hasenbeck
Abstract:To remain competitive in the wine market, wine comp anies must strive for a deeper understanding of the factors that influence consume rs at an emotional level in order to sustain consumer satisfaction. Evaluating the wine odor-ind uced emotional response, in addition to hedonic response and descriptive analysis, may prov ide valuable information into the perspective of the consumer and potentially insight to repeat p urchases. The objectives of this research were to measure the emotional responses elicited by odor attributes in wine samples and determine whether these emotional responses vary as function of cultural and experiential backgrounds, as well as sensory characteristics of wine odors. In S tudy 1 (Chapter 3), 10 trained panelists evaluated odor attributes of the five pre-selected wine samples; four specific odorants, linalool, 2,3-butanedione (diacetyl), 2,4,6-tricholoroanisole (TCA), and acetaldehyde, were added to the base wine to maximize the odor effect of sensory pe ception. The five wine samples were found to differ in the odor intensities of sulfur, moldy/ musty, honey, and leather attributes. In Study 2 (Chapter 4), French ( N = 86) and U.S. ( N = 89) participants rated their emotional responses elicited by the odors of five wine samples on the G neva Emotion and Odor Scale (GEOS). There were significant interactions between country and wine sample for the ratings of “wellbeing” and “excited” in emotional response. Signifi cant cross-cultural differences were obtained in the emotional responses evoked by the wines for 19 of the 36 terms, which led to the difference in the distribution of wine samples as s hown by principal component analysis between two countries. In addition, the emotional responses elicited by wine odors were different as a function of gender and previous reading of wine-rel ated literature. Furthermore, the odor of wine sample including TCA was rated at the least pleasan t in both countries. This study shows that emotional responses and hedonic responses, as well as sensory attributes can be modulated as a function of the odor of wine samples and consumer c ha acteristics such as gender and culture. A better understanding of the emotional effects of od ors found in wine, and how these effects vary among consumers, will allow the wine industry to de velop products with specific emotional impacts on users of different consumer groups. Acknowledgements I would first like to express my sincere gratitude to my advisor, Dr. Han-Seok Seo, for his time, patience and intellectual guidance in sen sory. I have learned so much through this experience, much of which I owe to you. Thank you f r your endless encouragement and determination throughout my path to becoming a sens ory cientist. I would also like to express my abundant appreciat ion to all my committee members: Dr. Jean-Francois Meullenet, Dr. Andy Mouramoustakos an d Dr. Robert Harrington. Each of you provided endless knowledge and guidance throughout t is process. Further, I would like to thank to the staff and fellow graduate students at the De partment of Food Science and Sensory Service Center. My very special thanks also go to the other resear chers who helped with my project: Dr. Renee Threlfall, Dr. Jordi Ballester and Dr. Christ elle Pecher. Renee, thank you so much for constantly encouraging me over the years and helpin g so much with planning the initial portion of my research. Without you, this would not be poss ible. Further, thank you for all the scholarship opportunities you provided me with and your guidance with those applications. Jordi and Christelle, I cannot tell you how thankful I am for my time with you in France. Both of you went above-and-beyond with accommodating me and see ing my research through in France. To my husband, Thomas, thank you so much. Your pat ience, understanding, motivation and unconditional love made this thesis possible. Thank you for believing in me and making me believe in myself. I know, at times, it was not an easy challenge. Last, but certainly not least, I would also like to express my deep gratitude to my family whose constant love and encouragement helped me achieve my goal. Dedication This thesis is dedicated to the loving memory of D r. Justin Morris, or “Doc,” who provided me with endless educational opportunities, encouragement and-best of all-laughter. Table of
Psychology,Business