Cost-effectiveness of craniotomy versus decompressive craniectomy for UK patients with traumatic acute subdural haematoma

Sarah Pyne,Garry Barton,David Turner,Harry Mee,Barbara A Gregson,Angelos G Kolias,Carole Turner,Hadie Adams,Midhun Mohan,Christopher Uff,Shumaila Hasan,Mark Wilson,Diederik Oliver Bulters,Ardalan Zolnourian,Catherine McMahon,Matthew G Stovell,Yahia Al-Tamimi,Simon Thomson,Edoardo Viaroli,Antonio Belli,Andrew King,Adel E Helmy,Ivan Timofeev,David Menon,Peter John Hutchinson,RESCUE-ASDH trial collaborators,Ivan S Timofeev,David K Menon,Peter J Hutchinson,Peter J Kirkpatrick,Nicola Owen,Kirsty Grieve,Alexis Joannides,Ellie Edlmann,Karen Caldwell,Silvia Tarantino,Francesca Hill,Liz Corteen,Janet Corn,Mathew Guilfoyle,Mohammad Naushahi,Richard Mair,Ibrahim Jalloh,Mark Kotter,Kamila Walker,Tamara Tajsic,Sara Venturini,Selma Tülü,Chipo Chitsenega,Geetha Boyapati,Muhammad Bhatti,Malik Zaben,Belinda Gunning,Natalia Ermalai,Dmitri Shastin,Mutwakil Abdulla,Joseph Merola Liudmila,Stuart Smith,Laurence Glanz,Ashwin Kumaria,Lani Patterson,Colin Bergin,Maximina Ventura,Emma Toman,Giles Critchley,Laura Ortiz-Ruiz de Gordoa,Prasanna Epaliyanage,Husam Georges,Peter Whitfield,Sam Jeffrey,Charlotte Eglinton,Natasha Wilmhurst,Manjunath Prasad,Shahid Khan,Philip Kane,Emanuel Cirstea,Geraint Sunderland,John Kitchen,Rushid Zakaria,Soumya Mukherjee,Ian Anderson,Linetty Makawa,Mary Kambafwile,Marios C Papadopoulos,Mathew JosephMathew JosephGallagher,Mathew Joseph,Siobhan Kearney,Sarah Trippier,Hani Marcus,Rhys Thomas,Sonia Fernandez Lopez,Louise Young,Andrea D'Mello,Jo-Anna Conyngham,Diederik Bulters,Patrick Holton,Miriam Taylor,Charlaine Reeve,Jonathan Pollock,Ciaran Hill,Elisa Visentin,Laura Parker,Kismet Hossain-Ibrahim,Paul Johnston,Vasileios Arzoglou,Emma Clarkson,Arif Zafar,Efosa Ukponmwan,Christos Tolias,Joseph Frantzias,Anastasios Giamouriadis,Adam Wahba,Patrick Easton,Rose Clegg,Grace Cole,Damian Holliman,Louise Finlay,Daniel Holsgrove,Alex Leggate,Jane Perez,Louise Harrison,Gareth Roberts,Terrie-Louise Cromie,Marianne Hare,Sonia Raj,Tim Lawrence,Ruichong Ma,Javier Magan Ventura,Neil Davidson,Richard Nelson,Ruth Womer,Beverley Fulkner,Shabin Joshi,Geraldine Ward,Ioannis Fouyas,Julie Woodfield,Himanshu Shekhar,Kareen Damley,Emma Fleming,Roddy O'Kane,Michael Canty,Indira Devi Bhagavatula,Dhananjaya Ishwar Bhat,Dhaval Prem Shukla,Kanti Konar,Nagesh Shanhag,Vaishali Nl Valluri,Manoj Kumar Tewari,Manjul Tripathi,Deepak Gupta,Ashish Bindra,Kaveri Sharma,Nicole Keong,Christine Lock,Chen Min Wei,Julian Han,Janell Kwok,Nicolas Kon,Kam King,Martina Stippler,Emmalin Nelton,Louis Anthony Whitworth,Sonja Stutzman,Christopher Madden,Caryn Harper,Tracey Moore,Vin Shen Ban,Alice Salazar,Rocco Armonda,Jason J Chang,George B Moses,Patricia Tanjucto,Jamie Ullman,Orseola Arapi,Betsy Moclair,Nrupen Baxi,Erin Lewis,Melvin Stone,John Adair Prall,Meghan Baldwin,Jamie Jones,Clare Gallagher,Ish Bains,Kesava Reddy,Paula Carroll,Leodante Da Costa,Nadia Scantlebury,Fahad Alkherayf,Rafael Ochoa Sanchez,Ioana Moldovan,Sean Christie,Lisa Julien,Kostas Fountas,Thanasis Paschalis,Sandro Krieg,Sebastian Ille,Maria Luisa,Gandia Gomez,Alfonso Legares,Ana Maria Castaño Leon,András Büki,Gábor Lenzsér,Tariq Khan,Mukhtar Khan,Franco Servadei,Massimo Tomei,Vairavan Narayanan,Ronie Romelean Jayapalan,Martin Hunn,Panagiota Gkolia,Emily Galea,Sarah C Pyne,Garry R Barton,David A Turner,Barbara Gregson,Paula Kareclas,Sridevi Nagarajan,James Piercy,Peter Kirkpatrick,A David Mendelow,John D Pickard,Paul Brennan,Christopher Cowie,Carol Davis-Wilkie,Tapiwa Tungamirai,Kerstin Wolf,Natalia Igosheva,Alicia Gore,Michele Jillings,Christopher Bushell,Anthony Bell,Allison Hirst,Peter McCabe,Simon Shaw,Martin Smith,Joan Grieve,Jonathan Cook
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmjopen-2024-085084
IF: 3.006
2024-06-16
BMJ Open
Abstract:Objective: To estimate the cost-effectiveness of craniotomy, compared with decompressive craniectomy (DC) in UK patients undergoing evacuation of acute subdural haematoma (ASDH). Design: Economic evaluation undertaken using health resource use and outcome data from the 12-month multicentre, pragmatic, parallel-group, randomised, Randomised Evaluation of Surgery with Craniectomy for Patients Undergoing Evacuation-ASDH trial. Setting: UK secondary care. Participants: 248 UK patients undergoing surgery for traumatic ASDH were randomised to craniotomy (N=126) or DC (N=122). Interventions: Surgical evacuation via craniotomy (bone flap replaced) or DC (bone flap left out with a view to replace later: cranioplasty surgery). Main outcome measures: In the base-case analysis, costs were estimated from a National Health Service and Personal Social Services perspective. Outcomes were assessed via the quality-adjusted life-years (QALY) derived from the EuroQoL 5-Dimension 5-Level questionnaire (cost-utility analysis) and the Extended Glasgow Outcome Scale (GOSE) (cost-effectiveness analysis). Multiple imputation and regression analyses were conducted to estimate the mean incremental cost and effect of craniotomy compared with DC. The most cost-effective option was selected, irrespective of the level of statistical significance as is argued by economists. Results: In the cost-utility analysis, the mean incremental cost of craniotomy compared with DC was estimated to be -£5520 (95% CI -£18 060 to £7020) with a mean QALY gain of 0.093 (95% CI 0.029 to 0.156). In the cost-effectiveness analysis, the mean incremental cost was estimated to be -£4536 (95% CI -£17 374 to £8301) with an OR of 1.682 (95% CI 0.995 to 2.842) for a favourable outcome on the GOSE. Conclusions: In a UK population with traumatic ASDH, craniotomy was estimated to be cost-effective compared with DC: craniotomy was estimated to have a lower mean cost, higher mean QALY gain and higher probability of a more favourable outcome on the GOSE (though not all estimated differences between the two approaches were statistically significant). Ethics: Ethical approval for the trial was obtained from the North West-Haydock Research Ethics Committee in the UK on 17 July 2014 (14/NW/1076). Trial registration number: ISRCTN87370545.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?