Abstract:Bones and teeth represent a common finding in ancient DNA studies and in forensic casework, even after a long burial. Genetic typing is the gold standard for the personal identification of skeletal remains, but there are two main factors involved in the successful DNA typing of such samples: (1) the set-up of an efficient DNA extraction method; (2) the identification of the most suitable skeletal element for the downstream genetic analyses. In this paper, a protocol based on the processing of 0.5 g of bone powder decalcified using Na2EDTA proved to be suitable for a semi-automated DNA extraction workflow using the Maxwell® FSC DNA IQTM Casework Kit (Promega, Madison, WI, USA). The performance of this method in terms of DNA recovery and quality was compared with a full demineralisation extraction protocol based on Qiagen technology and kits. No statistically significant differences were scored according to the DNA recovery and DNA degradation index (p-values ≥ 0.176; r ≥ 0.907). This new DNA extraction protocol was applied to 88 bone samples (41 femurs, 19 petrous bones, 12 metacarpals and 16 molars) allegedly belonging to 27 World War II Italian soldiers found in a mass grave on the isle of Cres (Croatia). The results of the qPCR performed by the Quantifiler Human DNA Quantification kit showed values above the lowest Limit of Quantification (lLOQ; 23 pg/μL) for all petrous bones, whereas other bone types showed, in most cases, lower amounts of DNA. Replicate STR-CE analyses showed successful typing (that is, >12 markers) in all tests on the petrous bones, followed by the metacarpals (83.3%), femurs (52.2%) and teeth (20.0%). Full profiles (22/22 autosomal markers) were achieved mainly in the petrous bones (84.2%), followed by the metacarpals (41.7%). Stochastic amplification artefacts such as drop-outs or drop-ins occurred with a frequency of 1.9% in the petrous bones, whereas they were higher when the DNA recovered from other bone elements was amplified (up to 13.9% in the femurs). Overall, the results of this study confirm that petrous bone outperforms other bone elements in terms of the quantity and quality of the recovered DNA; for this reason, if available, it should always be preferred for genetic testing. In addition, our results highlight the need for accurate planning of the DVI operation, which should be carried out by a multi-disciplinary team, and the tricky issue of identifying other suitable skeletal elements for genetic testing. Overall, the results presented in this paper support the need to adopt preanalytical strategies positively related to the successful genetic testing of aged skeletal remains in order to reduce costs and the time of analysis.

DNA preservation in compact and trabecular bone

The Mysteries of DNA preservation in bone: A Comparative study of Petrous Bones and Metacarpal Epiphyses using ATR-FTIR Spectroscopy

Bone fragment or bone powder? ATR-FTIR spectroscopy-based comparison of chemical composition and DNA preservation of bones after 10 years in a freezer

Searching for alternative high DNA-yielding bone types for DNA analysis of aged skeletal remains

Petrous bones versus tooth cementum for genetic analysis of aged skeletal remains

A fast and highly efficient automated DNA extraction method from small quantities of bone powder from aged bone samples

DNA profiling from human bone cells in the absence of decalcification and DNA extraction

Evaluation of a New DNA Extraction Method on Challenging Bone Samples Recovered from a WWII Mass Grave

Comparing preservation substrates under field conditions for efficient DNA recovery in bone

A comparison between petrous bone and tooth, femur and tibia DNA analysis from degraded skeletal remains

Human DNA extraction from highly degraded skeletal remains: How to find a suitable method?

Comparison of three methods of DNA extraction from human bones with different degrees of degradation

Novel contribution on the diagenetic physicochemical features of bone and teeth minerals, as substrates for ancient DNA typing

High efficiency DNA extraction from bone by total demineralization

An alternative procedure for extraction of DNA from ancient and weathered bone fragments

Unveiling Intra-Skeletal Variability in Mature and Immature Human Skeletal Remains via ATR-FTIR Spectroscopy

Validation process of automatic DNA extraction from bone material using a new advanced protocol for the EZ2 Connect instrument

A rapid and efficient method for DNA extraction from bone powder

Typing of Deoxyribonucleic Acid (DNA) Extracted from Compact Bone from Human Remains

Density separation of petrous bone powders for optimized ancient DNA yields

Factors influencing DNA extraction from human skeletal remains: bone characteristic and total demineralization process