Abstract:Economic choice theories usually assume that humans maximize utility in their choices. However, studies have shown that humans make inconsistent choices, leading to suboptimal behavior, even without context dependent manipulations. Previous studies showed that activation in value and motor networks are associated with inconsistent choices at the moment of choice. Here we investigated if the neural predispositions, measured before a choice task, can predict choice inconsistency in a later risk choice task. Using functional connectivity (FC) measures from resting-state functional magnetic resonance imaging (rsfMRI), derived before any choice was made, we aimed to predict subjects’ inconsistency levels in a later-performed choice task. We hypothesized that rsfMRI FC measures extracted from value and motor brain areas would predict inconsistency. Forty subjects (21 females) completed a rsfMRI scan before performing a risky-choice task. We compared models that were trained on FC that included only hypothesized value and motor regions with models trained on whole-brain FC. We found that both model types significantly predicted inconsistency levels. Moreover, even the whole-brain models relied mostly on FC between value and motor areas. For external validation, we used a neural network pre-trained on FC matrices of 40,000 subjects and fine-tuned it on our data, and again showed significant predictions. Together, this shows that the tendency for choice inconsistency is predicted by predispositions of the nervous system, and that synchrony between the motor and value networks plays a crucial role in this tendency. Significance Statement Humans often make irrational, or inconsistent, choices in value-based decision-making. Studies have suggested potential sources for this suboptimal behavior in momentary brain activity during choice, emphasizing the role of value and motor areas in the process of inconsistent choice behavior. Here, we show that inconsistency is predicted by neural predispositions, evident even before any choice was made. We predict subjects’ inconsistency levels from brain connectivity measures derived before they perform any choice task and find that inconsistency is predicted by the synchrony between the value and motor brain networks. This suggests choice inconsistency is related to a-priori constraints of the nervous system, and that value and motor areas play a central role in this behavior.

Intrinsic functional connectivity of motor and heteromodal association cortex predicts individual differences in regulatory focus

The Assessment Dimension of Regulatory Mode Mediates the Relation Between Frontoparietal Connectivity and Risk-Taking: Evidence from Voxel-Base Morphometry and Functional Connectivity Analysis

The Effect of Induced Regulatory Focus on Frontal Cortical Activity

Adaptive-to-maladaptive gradient of emotion regulation tendencies are embedded in the functional–structural hybrid connectome

Disrupted Intrinsic Functional Connectivity of the Cognitive Control Network Underlies Disease Severity and Executive Dysfunction in First-Episode, Treatment-Naive Adolescent Depression.

Individualized Prediction of Trait Self-Control from Whole-Brain Functional Connectivity.

Intrinsic connectivity networks underlying individual differences in control‐averse behavior

Pre-acquired functional connectivity predicts choice inconsistency

Between-module functional connectivity of the salient ventral attention network and dorsal attention network is associated with motor inhibition

Connectome-based prediction modeling of cognitive control using functional and structural connectivity

Individual Differences in Resting-State Functional Connectivity Predict Procrastination

354 Unitary neural correlates of executive control in pediatric transdiagnostic psychopathology

State-Dependent Effective Connectivity in Resting-State fMRI

Connectome-based Predictive Models of General and Specific Cognitive Control

Functional Connectivity Predicts Individual Development of Inhibitory Control during Adolescence

A Functional Subnetwork During Response Inhibition Revealed By Network-Based Statistics

Interpersonal traits and the neural representations of cognitive control in the prefrontal cortex

A neural network that links brain function, white-matter structure and risky behavior

The Motivation-Based Promotion of Proactive Control: the Role of Salience Network

How Do Regulatory Focus and the Big Five Relate to Work-domain Risk-taking? Evidence from Resting-state fMRI

The Lateral and Ventromedial Prefrontal Cortex Work as a Dynamic Integrated System: Evidence from fMRI Connectivity Analysis