The Association between Education Background and Fund Performance of Fund Managers
Ming-Chang Wang,Mingliang Cheng,Meng-Gu Tsai
2014-12-01
Abstract:IntroductionRecently, the need for higher education has become a considerably controversial topic. Scholars of all fields question whether academia and practice can be integrated seamlessly, and whether such integration is practicable in the workplace. This study aims at elucidating how the characteristics and education backgrounds of fund managers correlate with the performance of the funds they manage. According to Chevalier and Ellison (1999a), the perfonnance of funds operated by managers who attain an MBA from one of the top 30 schools listed by Business Week is superior to those operated by fund managers who receive their education at other schools. The findings of that study also show that fund perfonnance is unassociated with fund managers who have postgraduate degrees.Numerous scholars contend that gender influences work perfonnance, claiming that men are more willing to take risks, and they are more confident in strategy fonnulation. Previous studies indicate that a glass ceiling is common, even in businesses in Chinese communities. However, Atkinson, Baird, and Frye (2003) report that gender does not have a significant influence on fund performance.Heilman et al. (1989) and Oakley (2000) explore gender as a variable of fund manager characteristics and show that men outperform women in terms of work ability; consequently, investors are more willing to invest in funds that are managed by men. However, these claims are regarded as general stereotypes.In accordance with the research background and motivations, this study adopts an empirical analysis approach to determine the association between the education background of fund managers in Taiwan and the performance of the funds they operate, thereby providing an objective method for identifying the association between fund manager characteristics and fund performance. Investors can use the findings of This study as a reference when choosing investment funds.This paper is structured into 5 chapters. Chapter I presents the introduction, research motivations, and objectives, and Chapter II presents the findings of previous literatme in the fonn of a literature review. The research design is introduced in Chapter III, followed by a discussion regarding the various research variables and models. In, Chapter IV, the empirical results are discussed and the performance of fund managers with varying characteristics is compared. Finally, Chapter V offers the conclusion of this study and lists the recoimnendations proposed by the researchers.Literature ReviewFund Manager Characteristics and Fund PerformanceLin (2007) examines the performance of open-ended general equity funds in Taiwan for the 2006 financial year by using independent-sample t tests as well product-moment correlation and multiple regression analyses to determine the correlations among fund manager characteristics (e.g., gender, education, and years of service), operating characteristics (e.g., cash reserve ratio and structure of shareholding ratio), and fund performance. The findings of that study show that the funds managed by men significantly outperform those operated by women.Ke (2007) examines the performance of open-ended equity funds in Taiwan between 2000 and 2007 by using a Carhart Four-Factor Model and t tests to determine the influences of fund manager characteristics (e.g., gender, location of education, professional qualifications, and educational attainment) on their fund performance and career advancement. The findings of that study show that the stock-picking ability of female fund managers is superior to that of their male counterparts.Golee (1996) examines the mutual funds recorded in the Mutual Fund Sourcebook Volume published by Momingstar Inc. between 1988 and 1990. The researcher uses a three-stage least squares approach to determine the influences that fund manager traits have on fund performance, risk, and expense. In addition to fund manager characteristics (e. …
Economics,Business,Education