Abstract:How enhancers regulate their target genes in the context of 3D chromatin organization is extensively studied and models which do not require direct enhancer-promoter contact have recently emerged. Here, we use the activation of estrogen receptor-dependent enhancers in a breast cancer cell line to study enhancer-promoter communication at two loci. This allows high temporal resolution tracking of molecular events from hormone stimulation to efficient gene activation. We examine how both enhancer-promoter spatial proximity assayed by DNA fluorescence in situ hybridization, and contact frequencies resulting from chromatin in situ fragmentation and proximity ligation, change dynamically during enhancer-driven gene activation. These orthogonal methods produce seemingly paradoxical results: upon enhancer activation enhancer-promoter contact frequencies increase while spatial proximity decreases. We explore this apparent discrepancy using different estrogen receptor ligands and transcription inhibitors. Our data demonstrate that enhancer-promoter contact frequencies are transcription independent whereas altered enhancer-promoter proximity depends on transcription. Our results emphasize that the relationship between contact frequencies and physical distance in the nucleus, especially over short genomic distances, is not always a simple one. Investigating the three-dimensional organization of the genome is important for understanding how enhancers regulate their target genes. Commonly, exploring 3D genome organization uses either an imaging-based method—DNA fluorescence in situ hybridization, or molecular chromosome conformation capture methods. Here we use a cell system of nuclear hormone induced enhancer and gene activation to compare what insight into enhancer–gene promoter interaction these methodologies provide. To our surprise, we found that these two methods can produce paradoxical results, with increased enhancer-promoter contact frequencies assayed by chromosome conformation capture occurring in a situation where imaging shows overall decreased enhancer-promoter proximity. We explore what might contribute to these seemingly discrepant data, demonstrating that whereas increased enhancer-promoter contact frequencies require binding of an active transcription factor to the enhancer but are independent of transcription per se, altered enhancer-promoter proximity depends on transcription. Our analyses show the importance of using orthogonal methods to fully explore 3D genome organization.

Cis-regulatory control of transcriptional timing and noise in response to estrogen

-regulatory control of transcriptional timing and noise in response to estrogen

Epigenomics-based Identification of Oestrogen-Regulated Long Noncoding RNAs in ER+ Breast Cancer.

Single-cell Multi-Scale Footprinting Reveals the Modular Organization of DNA Regulatory Elements

Estrogen-induced chromatin looping changes identify a subset of functional regulatory elements

Integration of RNA-seq and Ribosome Profiling to Characterize Transcriptional and Translational Estrogen Responses of Genes in Human Breast Cancer

Integrative genomics of gene and metabolic regulation by estrogen receptors α and β, and their coregulators

Enhancer RNAs Mediate Estrogen-Induced Decommissioning of Selective Enhancers by Recruiting Erα and Its Cofactor

Cis-Regulatory Logic Produces Gene-Expression Noise Describing Phenotypic Heterogeneity in Bacteria

Transcription decouples estrogen-dependent changes in enhancer-promoter contact frequencies and spatial proximity

Controlled noise: evidence of epigenetic regulation of single-cell expression variability

A modulated empirical Bayes model for identifying topological and temporal estrogen receptor α regulatory networks in breast cancer

Interactome Maps of Mouse Gene Regulatory Domains Reveal Basic Principles of Transcriptional Regulation.

Acute Activation of Genes Through Transcriptional Condensates Impact Non-target Genes in a Chromatin Domain

Role of Nuclear Receptor Condensates in Ligand Induced Co‐operative Gene Regulation

Divergent regulatory element programs steer sex-specific supporting cell differentiation along mouse gonadal development

Mechanistic analysis of enhancer sequences in the estrogen receptor transcriptional program

Multimodal screen reveals noise regulatory proteins

Transcriptional Regulation Prediction of Antiestrogen Resistance in Breast Cancer Based on RNA Polymerase II Binding Data.

Characterization of Single-Cell Cis-regulatory Elements Informs Implications for Cell Differentiation.

Cis-Regulatory Elements in Mammals