Abstract:Advances in information technology are increasing the use of radar as a tool to investigate and monitor bird migration movements. We set up a field campaign to compare and validate outputs from different radar systems. Here we compare the pattern of nocturnal bird migration movements recorded by four different radar systems at a site in southern Sweden. Within the range of the weather radar (WR) Ängelholm, we operated a “BirdScan” (BS) dedicated bird radar, a standard marine radar (MR), and a tracking radar (TR). The measures of nightly migration intensities, provided by three of the radars (WR, BS, MR), corresponded well with respect to the relative seasonal course of migration, while absolute migration intensity agreed reasonably only between WR and BS. Flight directions derived from WR, BS and TR corresponded very well, despite very different sample sizes. Estimated mean ground speeds differed among all four systems. The correspondence among systems was highest under clear sky conditions and at high altitudes. Synthesis and applications. While different radar systems can provide useful information on nocturnal bird migration, they have distinct strengths and weaknesses, and all require supporting data to allow for species level inference. Weather radars continuously detect avian biomass flows across a wide altitude band, making them a useful tool for monitoring and predictive applications at regional to continental scales that do not rely on resolving individuals. BirdScan and marine radar’s strengths are in local and low altitude applications, such as collision risks with man‐made structures and airport safety, although marine radars should not be trusted for absolute intensities of movement. In quantifying flight behaviour of individuals, tracking radars are the most informative. While different radar systems can provide useful information on nocturnal bird migration, they have distinct strengths and weaknesses, and all require supporting data to allow for species level inference. Weather radars continuously detect avian biomass flows across a wide altitude band, making them a useful tool for monitoring and predictive applications at regional to continental scales that do not rely on resolving individuals. BirdScan and marine radar’s strengths are in local and low altitude applications, such as collision risks with man‐made structures and airport safety, although marine radars should not be trusted for absolute intensities of movement. In quantifying flight behaviour of individuals, tracking radars are the most informative.

Lidar as a potential tool for monitoring migratory insects

Spatial Monitoring of Flying Insects over a Swedish Lake Using a Continuous-Wave Lidar System

Application of lidar remote sensing of insects in agricultural entomology on the Chinese scene

3D-Printed Fluorescence Hyperspectral Lidar for Monitoring Tagged Insects

The Bat–bird–bug Battle: Daily Flight Activity of Insects and Their Predators over a Rice Field Revealed by High-Resolution Scheimpflug Lidar

Continental-scale patterns in diel flight timing of high-altitude migratory insects

Insect Diversity Estimation in Polarimetric Lidar

Monitoring of Flying Insects using a Dual-Wavelength CW Lidar System

Insect Abundance over Chinese Rice Fields in Relation to Environmental Parameters, Studied with a Polarization-Sensitive CW Near-Ir Lidar System

Effects of nocturnal celestial illumination on high-flying migrant insects

Agricultural pest monitoring using fluorescence lidar techniques

Convergent patterns of long-distance nocturnal migration in noctuid moths and passerine birds

Insect Remote Sensing Using a Polarization Sensitive Cw Lidar System in Chinese Rice Fields

Primary application of millimetric scanning radar to tracking high-flying insects in southern China

Photonic sensors reflect variation in insect abundance and diversity across habitats

Field validation of radar systems for monitoring bird migration

DEVELOPMENT OF A SCHEIMPFLUG LIDAR SYSTEM FOR ATMOSPHERIC AEROSOL MONITORING

Monitoring the abundance of flying insects and atmospheric conditions during a 9-month campaign using an entomological optical sensor

Advances in automatic identification of flying insects using optical sensors and machine learning

Automating insect monitoring using unsupervised near-infrared sensors