Individualised, perioperative open-lung ventilation strategy during one-lung ventilation (iPROVE-OLV): a multicentre, randomised, controlled clinical trial
Carlos Ferrando,Albert Carramiñana,Patricia Piñeiro,Lucia Mirabella,Savino Spadaro,Julián Librero,Fernando Ramasco,Gaetano Scaramuzzo,Oriol Cervantes,Ignacio Garutti,Ana Parera,Marta Argilaga,Gracia Herranz,Carmen Unzueta,Marc Vives,Kevin Regi,Marta Costa-Reverte,María Sonsoles Leal,Jesús Nieves-Alonso,Esther García,Aurelio Rodríguez-Pérez,Roberto Fariña,Sergio Cabrera,Elisabeth Guerra,Lucia Gallego-Ligorit,Alba Herrero-Izquierdo,J Vallés-Torres,Silvia Ramos,Daniel López-Herrera,Manuel De La Matta,Sertcakacilar Gokhan,Evrim Kucur,Ana Mugarra,Marina Soro,Laura García,José Alfonso Sastre,Pilar Aguirre,Claudia Jimena Salazar,María Carolina Ramos,Diego Rolando Morocho,Ramón Trespalacios,Félix Ezequiel-Fernández,Angella Lamanna,Leonarda Pia Cantatore,Donato Laforgia,Soledad Bellas,Carlos López,Ricard Navarro-Ripoll,Samira Martínez,Jordi Vallverdú,Adriana Jacas,María José Yepes-Temiño,Francisco Javier Belda,Gerardo Tusman,Fernando Suárez-Sipmann,Jesús Villar,iPROVE-OLV Research Network Group,Maria Sonsoles Leal,Jose Alfonso Sastre,Claudia Jimena-Salazar,Féliz Ezequiel-Fernández,Leonarda P Cantatore,Donato Laforogia,Maria José Yepes-Temiño,Selene Martinez,Gonzalo Azparren,Marc Bausili,Silvia Torres,María Díaz,Ana Ricart,Iñaki Gascó,Fina Parramon,Maite Sanz-Iturbe,Sara García-Ballester,Esther Méndez-Arias,Rafael Cabadas,Laura Grosso,Ángel Becerra,Zoraya Hussein,T Alberto Sanjuán-Villarreal,María Puértolas,Blanca Izquierdo-Villarroya,Rosa Almajano,Blanca Romero,Lorena Colomina,Natividad Quesada,José Antonio Latorre,José Antonio Franco,Anaïs Laval,Javier García-Tirado,Raúl Embún,Cristina Bueno,Paula Jarén,Raquel Martínez-Serrano,Beatriz García-Latasa,Sonia Baquedano,Begoña Motilva,Belén Hernando,Miriam Herrero,Pablo Oliver-Forniés,José Luis Recuero,Fernando Carbó-Espinosa,Alejandro Lucas,Nadia Muñoz-González,Noelia Lafuente,Jesús Acosta-Martínez,Riccardo Ragazzi,Carlo Alberto Volta,Pio Maniscalco,María Pilar Arribas,María Isabel de Celis,María Jesús Pascual,Pedro Martínez,Olga Martínez,José Ramón Repáraz,David Domínguez,Marta Fernández,Víctor Sánchez,Blanca Pérez-Lozana,Eliseba Martín,David Fernández,Adrian González,Jandro Pico,Dalia Ahmed El-Hefny,Laura Armengol,Óscar Comino,Irene Rovira,María José Arguis,Purificación Matute,María José Carretero,Cristina Ibáñez,Juan Perdomo,Cristina Ruiz,Nel González,Miren González,Ana Bolado,Sonia Trabanco,Ángela Largo,Alejandro Maestro,Ángela Pascual,Adriana Ixquic Reyes,María José Bartolomé,Mónica Mercedes Williams,Pablo Del Olmo,Bonifacio Cimadevilla,Sara Pardo,Laura Sancho,Laura Lascorz,José Antonio Carbonell,Luis Hurtado,Raluca Florea,Sara Martínez-Castro,Berta Monleón,Sara Pérez,Ana Jurado,Elizabeth Barcena,Nasara Segura,Javier Cuervo,Luis Belmonte,Pablo Pardo,Esther Utrera,Ferran Serralta,María José Parra,Blanca Arocas,Andrea Gutiérrez,Patricia Cruz-Pardos,Francisco de la Gala-García,Guillermo Sánchez-Pedrosa,Patricia Duque-González,Elena De La Fuente-Tornero,Ángela Puig-Ramos,Santiago García-Hernández,David Martínez-Gascueña,Carlos Alberto Calvo-García,Almudena Reyes-Fierro,Emma Novoa-Lago,Rafael Anaya-Camacho,Cristina Monteserín-Matesanz,Nuria Martínez-Merino,Ana Arnalich-Montiel,Ana Gloria Pizarro-Calderón,Adela Ruiz-Ortega,Pilar Benito-Saz,Adoración Elvira Rodríguez,Beatriz García-Bünger,Sergio García-Ramos,Elena López-Gil,Mercedes Power-Esteban,Rafael Ramos-Fernándes,Raúl Sevilla-Bayón,Isabel Solchaga-Sánchez,Livio Tullo,Guido Gambetti,Antonio Carrideo,Alessandra Morelli,Davide Aiello,Stefania Spiga
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/S2213-2600(23)00346-6
Abstract:Background: It is uncertain whether individualisation of the perioperative open-lung approach (OLA) to ventilation reduces postoperative pulmonary complications in patients undergoing lung resection. We compared a perioperative individualised OLA (iOLA) ventilation strategy with standard lung-protective ventilation in patients undergoing thoracic surgery with one-lung ventilation. Methods: This multicentre, randomised controlled trial enrolled patients scheduled for open or video-assisted thoracic surgery using one-lung ventilation in 25 participating hospitals in Spain, Italy, Turkey, Egypt, and Ecuador. Eligible adult patients (age ≥18 years) were randomly assigned to receive iOLA or standard lung-protective ventilation. Eligible patients (stratified by centre) were randomly assigned online by local principal investigators, with an allocation ratio of 1:1. Treatment with iOLA included an alveolar recruitment manoeuvre to 40 cm H2O of end-inspiratory pressure followed by individualised positive end-expiratory pressure (PEEP) titrated to best respiratory system compliance, and individualised postoperative respiratory support with high-flow oxygen therapy. Participants allocated to standard lung-protective ventilation received combined intraoperative 4 cm H2O of PEEP and postoperative conventional oxygen therapy. The primary outcome was a composite of severe postoperative pulmonary complications within the first 7 postoperative days, including atelectasis requiring bronchoscopy, severe respiratory failure, contralateral pneumothorax, early extubation failure (rescue with continuous positive airway pressure, non-invasive ventilation, invasive mechanical ventilation, or reintubation), acute respiratory distress syndrome, pulmonary infection, bronchopleural fistula, and pleural empyema. Due to trial setting, data obtained in the operating and postoperative rooms for routine monitoring were not blinded. At 24 h, data were acquired by an investigator blinded to group allocation. All analyses were performed on an intention-to-treat basis. This trial is registered with ClinicalTrials.gov, NCT03182062, and is complete. Findings: Between Sept 11, 2018, and June 14, 2022, we enrolled 1380 patients, of whom 1308 eligible patients (670 [434 male, 233 female, and three with missing data] assigned to iOLA and 638 [395 male, 237 female, and six with missing data] to standard lung-protective ventilation) were included in the final analysis. The proportion of patients with the composite outcome of severe postoperative pulmonary complications within the first 7 postoperative days was lower in the iOLA group compared with the standard lung-protective ventilation group (40 [6%] vs 97 [15%], relative risk 0·39 [95% CI 0·28 to 0·56]), with an absolute risk difference of -9·23 (95% CI -12·55 to -5·92). Recruitment manoeuvre-related adverse events were reported in five patients. Interpretation: Among patients subjected to lung resection under one-lung ventilation, iOLA was associated with a reduced risk of severe postoperative pulmonary complications when compared with conventional lung-protective ventilation. Funding: Instituto de Salud Carlos III and the European Regional Development Funds.