Letter: Solitary thyroid nodule.

J. E. Richardson,J. Beaugié,C. Brown

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.1.5908.637

1974-03-30

British Medical Journal

Abstract:SIR,-We agree with the view expressed in your leading article (10 November, p. 310) that clinically solitary thyroid nodules should be removed surgically because some are malignant. A proportion of benign follicular colloid nodules and papillary and m dullary carcinomnas can be recognized by fineneedle biopsy, but follicular carcinoma cannot be distinguished from benign adenoma by needle biopsy and here frozen section is also unreliable. Lobectomy provides the tissue necessary for diagnosis and is the d,efinitive treatment for follicular carcinomas, which have a good prognosis.' In thyroid cancer we must consider the way the disease behaves and the possible effects of each type of treatment. The behaviour of papillary, follicular, and medullary thyroid cancers, which may present as a solitary nodule, is documented in the clinicopathological classification of Hazard2 and Woolner et al.,3 which is now widely accepted. Different classifications may confuse; for example, Russell's description4 of tumour spread within the thyroid is difficult to interpret because the HazardWoolner classification was not used. If it had been, however, the descriptions given plaoe at least 80°% of his carcinomas in the papillary group. Advocates of total thyroidectomy must define their aims since the behaviour of some thyroid carcinomas is remarkably "benign." Total thyroidectomy is more radical than is usually necessary and neither removes the primary en bloc with its lymphatic drainage nor reliably ablates all thyroid tissue as a preliminary to radioiodine treatment. Of its complications, Dr. H. J. Goldsmith (5 January, p. 39) mentions hypoparathyroidism. The incidence of this reported by ex-perienced thyroid surgeons is about 150% after total thyroidectomy and we have recorded that of 12 children operated on in England and Wales in 1962-67, five have hypoparathyroidism, from which one almost died.' The condition is serious and requires life-long treatment so that only if thyroid cancers were more "malignant" might one accept this penalty. In this respect Dr. Goldsmith's analogy with prostatic cancer reflects Crile's view of some of these tumours.1-We are, etc., J. E. RICHARDSON J. M. BEAUGI9 C. L. BROWN