Exacerbation of atopic dermatitis upon alkaline skin care

Carina Mercedes Butzmann,C. Schempp

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1610-0387.2011.07707.x

2011-09-01

Abstract:A 20-year-old patient with atopic diathesis rapidly worsened after using alkaline skin care products. The patient reported a history of atopic dermatitis since childhood which worsened after she had used alkaline skin care products on the face for 2 weeks. At the time of the patient’s first visit to our clinic, there were erythematous and impetigenized areas on the cheeks, forehead, and around the eyes (Figure 1). Tests confirmed a bacterial superinfection of the skin with Staphylococcus aureus. Total IgE was significantly elevated at 3044 kU/L and immediate hypersensitivity to timothy grass, European white birch, mugwort, wheat, peanut, soybean, and dog dander. The patient also had allergic rhinoconjunctivitis. Systemic antibiotics and topical treatment with prednicarbate ointment and black tea dressings led to rapid healing of weeping eczema. In atopic patients, there are more alkaline pH levels on the skin and a tendency toward colonization of the skin with pathogenic organisms [1, 2]. In a study by Eberlein-König and colleagues, the pH levels of the skin in children with atopic dermatitis were higher than in the comparison group with healthy children [3]. The increased pH levels in atopic patients are associated with increased pruritus, dryness of the skin, increased transepidermal water loss, and diminished secretion of sweat [3–5]. The physiological pH levels of the skin are acidic (5.5). At this pH level, the skin is colonized with naturally-occurring, typical flora. The acidic pH levels form a naturally acidic protective coating that helps defend against infection, irritation, and inflammation. If the pH balance is disturbed, the resulting alkaline milieu can promote the proliferation of pathogenic organisms and fungi [6]. In principle, any time the skin is washed there is dehydration of the skin, loss of skin lipids, and increased pH levels [7]. A prolonged and intense increase in pH levels has been shown in the use of diluted lye [8]. Cleansing of the skin with alkaline soaps also increases the pH level [9, 10]. There seems to be a trend toward alkaline skin cleansing and skin care products at the moment. The underlying philosophy is that the body is increasingly exposed to an acidic milieu and must secrete more acid through the intestine, kidneys, and skin. In this line of thinking, the acidic pH level of the skin is considered unhealthy, and alkaline skin care products are intended to help restore the balance. An Internet search of keywords “alkaline skin care products” leads to quotes such as this: “Is there really a protective acidic coating or not? [...] In the opinion of various experts in skin care, who for years have studied the use of alkaline skin care, there is no such thing.” “Up until the 1970s all soaps used for skin care were alkaline soaps. After that, the first modern skin care products conquered the market. Their chemical formulation and acidic pH levels destroy the natural regulation of the skin’s balance and thus promote the development of various skin diseases.” “Alkaline skin care products cleanse and promote the regeneration of the skin by thoroughly removing dead skin layers and enhancing the secretory function of the skin by osmosis.” These statements are without any rational justification and are a direct contradiction of all published scientific studies. The example of our patient shows the dramatic effects that the use of alkaline skin care products can have in people Exacerbation of atopic dermatitis upon alkaline skin care