Caring Science: Belonging Before Being as Ethical Cosmology

J. Watson
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/0894318405280395
2005-10-01
Nursing Science Quarterly
Abstract:The mainstream discourses in the field of ethics tend to be dominated by dualities: either biomedical-principle-based approaches to ethical decision making, or relational-caringfeminist-based ethics. The first view is often dealing with rational decision-making, related to public, neon-lights headlines of biomedical-technological ethical dilemmas; the second dealing with more intimate, private, relational contextual human-meaning ethical decisions. However, in reality, in the field, it is not either/or, but increasingly both/and. Together, these approaches, used simultaneously, are necessary for a more balanced integrated view. Together, this both/and view embraces the dynamics and vicissitudes of the medical-technical conditions embedded in the circumstances, as well as the complexities of the human dynamics and multiple meanings and relations informing the process for patients and practitioners. In a both/and ethical decisionmaking approach, an expanding model emerges that is especially relevant for nursing and the increasingly acknowledged, relational caring-context in which nursing dwells. However, what is revealed in the discourse of differing ethical approaches is an even deeper evolving perspective—a position that acknowledges that the worldview or the cosmology underlying one’s position informs any ethical starting point. This commentary takes this idea a step forward to posit an evolved cosmology, which evokes and uncovers a deeper ethical starting point—a starting point that is congruent with extant nursing theories, as well as evolving consciousness for sustaining humanity. I am framing this evolving starting point within the context of caring science. Caring science offers a cosmology for science and humanity alike, moving us toward a deeper ethic of human belonging that affects all. Caring Science as Ethic: Ethic as Cosmology
What problem does this paper attempt to address?