High-protein diet scores, macronutrient substitution, and breast cancer risk: insights from substitution analysis

Mitra Kazemi Jahromi,Hamid Ahmadirad,Hossein Farhadnejad,Mostafa Norouzzadeh,Ebrahim Mokhtari,Farshad Teymoori,Niloufar Saber,Zeinab Heidari,Parvin Mirmiran,Bahram Rashidkhani

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1186/s12905-024-02959-7

2024-02-16

Abstract:Abstract Background Evidence from recent studies suggested that variation in the quantity and quality of macronutrients in the diet may potentially play a role in predicting the risk of breast cancer (BC). In the current study, we aimed to assess the association of different high-protein diet scores and replacing fats and carbohydrate (CHO) with protein in the diet with the BC risk among Iranian women. Methods The current hospital-based case-control study was conducted on 401 participants, aged ≥ 30 years old, including 134 women in the case group who had been diagnosed with histologically confirmed BC and 267 women in the control group. Dietary intake data was collected using a validated food frequency questionnaire, and high protein diet scores were determined. Logistic regression models were used to determine the odds ratios (OR) and 95% confidence interval (CI) of BC across tertiles of high protein diet scores. Also, we assessed how substituting protein with other macronutrients affected BC odds while adjusting for the various confounding variables. Results Participants’ mean ± SD of age and body mass index were 47.9 ± 10.3 years and 29.4 ± 5.5 kg/m 2 , respectively. The scores of high-protein-low-CHO and fat diet, high-protein and CHO-low-fat diet, and high-protein and fat-low-CHO diet in participants were 16.5 ± 3.8, 16.5 ± 6.7, and 16.4 ± 5.9, respectively. In the multivariable model, individuals in the highest tertile of high-protein-low-CHO and fat diet score (OR:0.71;95%CI:0.56–0.90) and high-protein and CHO-low-fat diet (OR:0.76;95%CI:0.60–0.97) had lower odds of BC compared to those in the lowest tertile ( P < 0.05). However, no significant association was found between high-protein and fat-low-CHO diet and BC risk. Our results showed that replacing fat by protein (OR differences :-0.40;95%CI:-0.73,-0.07) and also replacing refined-CHO by plant protein (OR differences :-0.66;95%CI:-1.26,-0.07) in the diet are associated inversely with risk of BC( P < 0.05). Conclusions The results of our study suggested that higher adherence to a high-protein-low-CHO and fat diet, characterized by a higher intake of plant proteins and a lower intake of refined grains and saturated fat can play a protective role against the odds of BC.

public, environmental & occupational health,obstetrics & gynecology

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The main problem that this paper attempts to solve is to explore the relationship between different high - protein diet scores and the substitution of fat and carbohydrates in the diet with protein and the risk of breast cancer. Specifically, the study aims to evaluate the impact of different types of high - protein diet scores and the replacement of fat and carbohydrates in the diet with protein on the risk of breast cancer among Iranian women.

### Research Background
Breast cancer (BC) is a common malignant tumor, affecting approximately 1.5 million women globally each year, accounting for one - fourth of female cancers. In Iran, breast cancer is the third - leading cause of death among women, with an annual incidence of 8,000 cases, one - third of which occur in women under 30 years old. Although early diagnosis can improve treatment outcomes, the metastatic and multifactorial nature of breast cancer makes it difficult to treat effectively. Therefore, the medical system faces a greater economic burden, and breast cancer patients face the problems of early death and a decline in quality of life.

### Diet and Breast Cancer Risk
The protein intake in the diet may affect the risk of cancer, depending on the type and amount of protein consumed. For example, high red - meat consumption as a source of dietary protein accounts for 3.21% of breast cancer mortality. Some studies have shown that a high - protein diet may increase the risk of certain types of cancers, such as prostate cancer, esophageal cell carcinoma, and colon cancer. However, there is no clear conclusion regarding the relationship between a high - protein diet and breast cancer incidence or mortality.

### Research Objectives
In view of the contradictions in current research results, the increasing trend of breast cancer incidence in Iran, and the lack of research on the association between the quantity and quality of dietary protein and breast cancer risk in the Middle East and North Africa region, this study aims to explore the potential relationship between high - protein diet scores and the risk of breast cancer in Iranian adults. In addition, the study also uses substitution models to compare the relationships between different dietary protein sources and breast cancer risk.

### Main Findings
- **High - protein, low - carbohydrate and low - fat diet**: In the multivariable model, individuals in the highest tertile of the high - protein, low - carbohydrate and low - fat diet score group had a lower risk of breast cancer (OR: 0.71; 95% CI: 0.56 - 0.90).
- **High - protein and low - carbohydrate, low - fat diet**: Individuals in the highest tertile of the high - protein and low - carbohydrate, low - fat diet score group also had a lower risk of breast cancer (OR: 0.76; 95% CI: 0.60 - 0.97).
- **High - protein and low - fat, low - carbohydrate diet**: No significant association was found.
- **Substitution analysis**: Substituting protein for fat (OR difference: - 0.40; 95% CI: - 0.73, - 0.07) and substituting plant protein for refined carbohydrates (OR difference: - 0.66; 95% CI: - 1.26, - 0.07) were negatively correlated with the risk of breast cancer.

### Conclusions
The research results indicate that a higher degree of adherence to a high - protein, low - carbohydrate and low - fat diet, especially increasing the intake of plant protein and reducing the intake of refined grains and saturated fats, may have a protective effect on the prevention of breast cancer.